Lake gets four week ban... Petrie cleared

[AndrewP6]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-07-08/lake-banned-for-four

[bulldogtragic]

About right. Are the Hawks stupid enough to appeal?

Just read the bottom of that, it would appear not.

[ledge]

Hawks weren't happy with lake either so could hardly appeal it after saying themselves how it wasn't acceptable.

[Ghost Dog]

It's a very nasty way to hold someone with your weight on their throat like that.
Nice bit of revisionist journalism in Theage today, reminding all Bulldogs supporters of what they would rather forget.
He had his purple patches but my, had some choice moments of lunacy.

[bornadog]

Should have got 10 weeks

[Remi Moses]

Brian Brian Brian. Just seen it. My God!!
Petrie does strange things to Brian's mentality. Pretty stupid to be honest

[SonofScray]

One of the rare times they get it right. Thought 4 for Lake and 2 for Petrie would have covered it.

[LostDoggy]

One of the rare times they get it right. Thought 4 for Lake and 2 for Petrie would have covered it.

Except Petrie walked

[Greystache]

I'm obviously on my own, but I think Lake's been pretty harshly treated. He tackled Petrie and threw him to the ground, then Petrie throws his elbow and catches Lake in the head, then Lake grabs him around the head, then Petrie eye gouges him, so Lake grabs him by the throat.

Petrie instigated the confrontation, Petrie escalated the confrontation, Lake responded (too aggressively), and Petrie walks free while Lake gets 4 weeks. Lake was hung, drawn, and quartered before people even looked at the sequence of events. Petrie should have got 3 weeks and Lake 1-2.

[Bulldog Joe]

I'm obviously on my own, but I think Lake's been pretty harshly treated. He tackled Petrie and threw him to the ground, then Petrie throws his elbow and catches Lake in the head, then Lake grabs him around the head, then Petrie eye gouges him, so Lake grabs him by the throat.

Petrie instigated the confrontation, Petrie escalated the confrontation, Lake responded (too aggressively), and Petrie walks free while Lake gets 4 weeks. Lake was hung, drawn, and quartered before people even looked at the sequence of events. Petrie should have got 3 weeks and Lake 1-2.
Pretty hard to defend Lake when his own team were pouring petrol on the fire with their comments.

[Greystache]

Pretty hard to defend Lake when his own team were pouring petrol on the fire with their comments.

But that's my point, they did so before they'd even had a look at the sequence of events. I'd be willing to bet had they reviewed the footage first they wouldn't have been anywhere near as strong on Lake as they were in the immediate aftermath. They backed themselves into a corner with their initial reactions.

[Twodogs]

I'm obviously on my own, but I think Lake's been pretty harshly treated. He tackled Petrie and threw him to the ground, then Petrie throws his elbow and catches Lake in the head, then Lake grabs him around the head, then Petrie eye gouges him, so Lake grabs him by the throat.

Petrie instigated the confrontation, Petrie escalated the confrontation, Lake responded (too aggressively), and Petrie walks free while Lake gets 4 weeks. Lake was hung, drawn, and quartered before people even looked at the sequence of events. Petrie should have got 3 weeks and Lake 1-2.

Youre not on your own, I agree with you.

The tribunal has become the AFL's public pacifier. Rather than do what a proper legal panel would do-look at the facts and take the sequence of events into account then take precedent into account and come up with a calm, rational decision based on good legal principle it just goes along with whatever everyone lose thinks

[LostDoggy]

Youre not on your own, I agree with you.

The tribunal has become the AFL's public pacifier. Rather than do what a proper legal panel would do-look at the facts and take the sequence of events into account then take precedent into account and come up with a calm, rational decision based on good legal principle it just goes along with whatever everyone lose thinks
But are we, the public, to blame for that for rolling out The Outrage Machine every time they get it wrong in our eyes?

[Flamethrower]

I thought 4 weeks in total was about right for Brainfade and the Petri dish, BUT it should have been 2 weeks each. Brainfade only realy snapped after the Dish clawed at his eyes and face.

The only bonus for us is that Brainfade will miss our game in Tassie, so Big Jack can kick a bag on Schoenmakers.

[Sedat]

Agree with those who said Lake was harshly treated - more so the media treatment as opposed to the actual tribunal sentence handed out (I thought 3-4 weeks was around the mark). Obviously a slow news week for the AFL scribes. Meanwhile, there's a team full of (alleged) dopers who most of the scribes are treating with kid gloves and giving a tickle to the tummy.

[HOSE B ROMERO]

Was there any history between these two?

The only thing i remember was a game at the MCG (could have been Liam Picken's first game) when Petrie kicked 5 in the first qtr on Brian.
Still, hardly a reason to choke a guy...

[bornadog]

You can twist it any way you want but it wasn't a good look for the game.

[Scorlibo]

To me, from the vision, it doesn't look as though Lake chokes Petrie. He grabs him by the back of the neck and briefly applies pressure to the collarbone. When I watched it the first time through I actually thought it was the responsible way to proceed, given that he could have easily thrown punches at Petrie.

[LostDoggy]

To me, from the vision, it doesn't look as though Lake chokes Petrie. He grabs him by the back of the neck and briefly applies pressure to the collarbone. When I watched it the first time through I actually thought it was the responsible way to proceed, given that he could have easily thrown punches at Petrie.

Love your work.

[Twodogs]

Was there any history between these two?

The only thing i remember was a game at the MCG (could have been Liam Picken's first game) when Petrie kicked 5 in the first qtr on Brian.
Still, hardly a reason to choke a guy...


Petrie keeps kicking bags of goals on him. I kept having nightmares where Petrie is kicking goals from everywhere. He taking huge contested marks against Lake and out sprints him on the lead. Marking the ball with a smug smile on his face as Lake flailed behind him. Petrie would go back and slot his 5th or 6th for the quarter.