I was wrong and I am glad!

[mjp]

I said the Giants would NEVER trade Boyd. I was wrong. They caved.

I am glad I was wrong. Kudos to everyone involved.

[chef]

I'm so glad you are wrong:D

[Mofra]

I really didn't think we'd get him and said so yesterday and today.

Being wrong feels good :cool:

[bornadog]

I said the Giants would NEVER trade Boyd. I was wrong. They caved.

I am glad I was wrong. Kudos to everyone involved.

In reality they shouldn't have.

Great for us kudos to having a List Manager, makes a huge difference to a club.

[Bulldog Revolution]

I posted yesterday that they would, but I was probably hoping more than being sure it would happen

JMac and Simon seem to be working v.well together

[F'scary]

The nuance, I think, MJP is that prior to today we had not put pick 6 on the table with Griffen. On the straight swap proposal, which I think is what was on the table up to today, you were in fact correct.

[choconmientay]

I said the Giants would NEVER trade Boyd. I was wrong. They caved.

I am glad I was wrong. Kudos to everyone involved.

I wish this thread was started by always right ;)

[DOG GOD]

I was wrong too...I like to be wrong..on occasion haha....this occasion.

[mjp]

The nuance, I think, MJP is that prior to today we had not put pick 6 on the table with Griffen. On the straight swap proposal, which I think is what was on the table up to today, you were in fact correct.

No. I meant that they wouldn't trade him full stop - regardless of the offer. And they shouldn't have. A mistake that they will regret for 10years. You just don't get key forwards like this unless you finish last...they are not set up to finish last for a long time...better hope Patton comes back strong.

[Go_Dogs]

No. I meant that they wouldn't trade him full stop - regardless of the offer. And they shouldn't have. A mistake that they will regret for 10years. You just don't get key forwards like this unless you finish last...they are not set up to finish last for a long time...better hope Patton comes back strong.

Imagine if we finish in the bottom few next year and end up with two of them!

[comrade]

I was wrong, too. After the Giants CEO came out and categorically said he wouldn't be traded.

Now, we both look like gooses but I'm a happy goose.