Welcome to the Western Bulldogs - Ed Richards

[bulldogtragic]

Welcome!

(Just getting in early to help)

[bulldogtragic]

Ed Richards

Seconds: 25

[GVGjr]

Really happy with Ed Richards coming to us.

[choconmientay]

Happy to have you with us :)

Ed Richards highlights - 2017 draft prospect

https://youtu.be/LnIipqFM7P0

[Eastdog]

Welcome to the Dogs Ed Richards

[choconmientay]

Tomorrow's Heroes - Ed Richards

https://youtu.be/cArI0LgZC0A

[Go_Dogs]

You’ve backed him in for a while GVG, well done.

Happy to add some serious wheels to our list, thought we might snare Murphy or L Fogarty but happy with this one. I bet Dal wishes he had another pick in the first 20!

[choconmientay]

https://youtu.be/ZYh9SWkRWDo
Ed Richards TACcupRnd17

[GVGjr]

Happy to add some serious wheels to our list, thought we might snare Murphy or L Fogarty but happy with this one. I bet Dal wishes he had another pick in the first 20!
Embarrassment of riches still available.

We would have been happy with Murphy or L.Fogarty

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Love this pick

[comrade]

Looks like Ron Weasley, I like him already.

[Remi Moses]

Nice left foot . Good speed also ( on the highlights )

[bornadog]

A steal at 16, welcome aboard.

Height: 185cm
Weight: 78kg
DOB: 3 July, 1999
Position: Half Back
Club: Oakleigh Chargers

[Mofra]

Has midfield potential too

[anfo27]

does he have a right foot?

[GVGjr]

does he have a right foot?

Does he need it? ;) He is very one sided but he will adjust. He will win over the fans and a mate reckons the red hair reminds him of Brad Hardie :)

[anfo27]

Does he need it? ;) He is very one sided but he will adjust. He will win over the fans and a mate reckons the red hair reminds him of Brad Hardie :)

I like what i see

[Sedat]

Richards follows the Dalrymple patented 'rapid improvement in his U18 season' blueprint to the letter - it has served us very well in the past

[GVGjr]

Richards follows the Dalrymple patented 'rapid improvement in his U18 season' blueprint to the letter - it has served us very well in the past

Also players from the Oakleigh Chargers have served us well.

[Bulldog Revolution]

I was almost ready to draft him with 9 so to get him and Naughton is a great outcome

[bornadog]

Simon Dalrymple re: Ed Richards: "Obviously with Bob Murphy departing, a running half-back was a good fit"

[GVGjr]

Simon Dalrymple re: Ed Richards: "Obviously with Bob Murphy departing, a running half-back was a good fit"

And he might even allow JJ to move forward.

[KT31]

Welcome to the Doggies Ed.

[Smads57]

Welcome to the Doggies Ed, you'll certainly be easy to spot on the field with that red mane of yours!

[jeemak]

And he might even allow JJ to move forward.

in about four years when he should genuinely come good.

We've been spoiled by the progress of the likes of Bont, Stringer, McLean, Macrae and few others. If true to form of most draftees, he won't be taking JJ's role away any time soon.

[LostDoggy]

He looks a real metreage player. Good burst out of packs and seems to hit a lot of targets by foot. Exciting prospect.

[bulldogtragic]

Simon Dalrymple: "Ed Richards is a running half-back who we were prepared to pick at nine but we were happy to get him at 16 which is always a bonus."

[GVGjr]

Some Draft Combine results for Richards

184.7cm, 78.1kg
Running Vertical Jump 80cm (top 25% of players tested)
Sprints 5mtr 1.11, 10mtr 1.81 and 20mtr 3.01 (top 25% for each distance of the players tested)
Agility and Yo-Yo tests were not strong and his 2km was a tick under 7mins

He needs to build up his aerobic base.

[Eastdog]

Nice left foot . Good speed also ( on the highlights )

Yep that certainly was a huge plus in the highlights.

[LostDoggy]

Richards follows the Dalrymple patented 'rapid improvement in his U18 season' blueprint to the letter - it has served us very well in the past

I did notice in one report that Richards recently grew 15 cm in a year. This seems another trait that often pops up in Dal selections.

[Twodogs]

I did notice in one report that Richards recently grew 15 cm in a year. This seems another trait that often pops up in Dal selections.

In year nine I grew just under an average of a cm every week. I wish Dal was recruiting back then...

[Dry Rot]

Is Richards a vote of no confidence in Williams?

[bulldogtragic]

Is Richards a vote of no confidence in Williams?

I don't think so. It may be that others (JJ or Williams etc) or Richards can play wing or further up. If Richards can hit targets by foot inside 50 I'm happy to see him on the wing.

[Rocket Science]

Dash, dare, creativity and an ability to execute.

I've heard the Heath Shaw comparison but bugger that, he's Rohan Smith mach-2, and he'll be learning from him first hand.

[bulldogtragic]

Dash, dare, creativity and an ability to execute.

I've heard the Heath Shaw comparison but bugger that, he's Rohan Smith mach-2, and he'll be learning from him first hand.

Yep. Refuses to point at team mates and berate them for his mistakes either... So Bubba is more apt.

[Twodogs]

Yep. Refuses to point at team mates and berate them for his mistakes either... So Bubba is more apt.


Rohan Smith would make his point if he thought you let him down. Just not in front of 45 000 people, the opposition and 20 teammates.

[macca]

Richards is a great pickup reading some of the posts and new articles on him.

Did not realize that he was grandson of Ron richards, who was Lou brother. He has great pedigree from both sides of his parents, good article here.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/afl-draft-ed-richards-is-a-bulldog-with-magpie-blood-running-through-his-veins-20171125-gzssmz.html

Really rapt with this recruit and hope he can become a 200 game player for us. Even happier that we pinched him from the pies.

[GVGjr]

Is Richards a vote of no confidence in Williams?

I don't think so they're very different players. Richards will primarily play on the quicker types.

[Twodogs]

Richards is a great pickup reading some of the posts and new articles on him.

Did not realize that he was grandson of Ron richards, who was Lou brother. He has great pedigree from both sides of his parents, good article here.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/afl-draft-ed-richards-is-a-bulldog-with-magpie-blood-running-through-his-veins-20171125-gzssmz.html

Really rapt with this recruit and hope he can become a 200 game player for us. Even happier that we pinched him from the pies.

That's interesting. We had a teacher at school called miss Richards (her first name was Sian from memory) and she was Lou's granddaughter. She must be be Ed's Aunty I guess. Or cousin if Ed is Ron's grandson.

[Bulldog4life]

That's interesting. We had a teacher at school called miss Richards (her first name was Sian from memory) and she was Lou's granddaughter. She must be be Ed's Aunty I guess. Or cousin if Ed is Ron's grandson.

His grandfather Ron was a very good player for Collingwood too.

[Twodogs]

His grandfather Ron was a very good player for Collingwood too.


I remember Ron. He was Collingwood's assistant coach for years when I was a kid.

[Bulldog4life]

I remember Ron. He was Collingwood's assistant coach for years when I was a kid.

That's correct. He worked closely with a number of their senior coaches over many years.

[Twodogs]

That's correct. He worked closely with a number of their senior coaches over many years.

It's interesting. Ed's family tree takes him right back to the Pannams who played in Collingwood's 1896 VFA premiership and in the first years of the VFL. It was Alby Pannam with Dick Condon who took footy from a static game where possession and territory meant everything to a running game like it is now one afternoon in Tasmania when they were bored with the opposition and started chipping the ball just over their heads to each other.

He has quite a football heritage.

[bornadog]

It's interesting. Ed's family tree takes him right back to the Pannams who played in Collingwood's 1896 VFA premiership and in the first years of the VFL. It was Alby Pannam with Dick Condon who took footy from a static game where possession and territory meant everything to a running game like it is now one afternoon in Tasmania when they were bored with the opposition and started chipping the ball just over their heads to each other.

He has quite a football heritage.

Story about his heritage:

Ed Richards is a Bulldog with Magpie blood running through his veins (http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/afl-draft-ed-richards-is-a-bulldog-with-magpie-blood-running-through-his-veins-20171125-gzssmz.html)


With a crop of red hair like a burning front, Western Bulldogs recruit Ed Richards doesn't exactly resemble his Collingwood premiership-winning grandfather Ron Richards.

But as soon as Western Bulldogs' recruiting manager Simon Dalrymple laid eyes on Ed's dad Kane when he visited the family home, he knew he was dealing with a clan carrying famous Collingwood blood.

https://www.fairfaxstatic.com.au/content/dam/images/g/z/s/t/1/9/image.related.articleLeadwide.620x349.gzssmz.png/1511585227961.jpg

"Kane is a dead ringer for Ron," Dalrymple said.
Ron Richards was a lifelong servant of Collingwood, playing 143 games for the Magpies, including the 1953 premiership alongside his more famous brother Lou, who was the skipper.

Ron lived and breathed Collingwood before and after his playing career ended in 1956, serving as reserves coach, on the match committee, on the board and as a trusted sidekick to a succession of Collingwood coaches including Tom Hafey and Leigh Matthews.

Quieter than 'Louie the Lip', the late Ron Richards, who died in 2013, earned a reputation as a big game player with many claiming he was best on ground playing off a wing in the 1953 triumph.


http://www.smh.com.au/content/dam/images/g/w/0/a/i/v/image.imgtype.articleLeadwide.620x349.png/1494224232756.png

Collingwood flag heroes Ron (left) and Lou Richards. Ron's grandson Ed has joined the Dogs.


Dalrymple, for his part, had become keen on 18-year-old Ed as he watched the youngster grow from a skinny Carey Grammar student to a tearaway Oakleigh Chargers defender in the space of just 18 months as he roared up the draft charts.

"His development during the year was really impressive," Dalrymple said.
But nowhere near as impressive as his football lineage which stretches as far back as 1894.
That's because Ron and Lou also had a famous footballing grandfather on their mum's side.

He was Charlie Pannam, who began with Collingwood VFA from 1894-1896 then became a VFL player with the club from 1897-1907, before spending one season as captain-coach at Richmond when the Tigers joined the league in 1908.

Pannam, who had a Greek heritage but shortened his name from Pannamopoulos, was a footballing pioneer who was inducted into the Australian Football Hall of Fame in 1996.

Along with a three other family members, another Charlie and two Alberts, the Pannam dynasty yielded 939 games, mostly with the Magpies but also with stints at Richmond and South Melbourne.

Now Ed has the chance to add to that games tally after the Bulldogs selected him with pick 16 in the national draft.
While that moment might have caused the hearts of some diehard Magpies to skip a beat, connecting a famous Collingwood name to the Bulldogs is a positive result from an historical perspective.

After all Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge knows better than most what it is like to have a famous grandfather play for the Pies.
His grandfather, Jack, played for Collingwood in the quartet of premierships in the late 1930s but Luke played with the Bulldogs, Melbourne and St Kilda before taking the Bulldogs to the drought-breaking 2016 flag.

The Rose family connection to the Bulldogs has also seen the two clubs compete for the Robert Rose Cup since 2000.
So the Richards link only charges the current running between the two clubs further.

Regardless of his football background, it was Ed's pace and class that made the Bulldogs want him.
"He's composed. He doesn't panic with the ball and he can defend," Dalrymple said.
Eventually, they think Ed might replace a similarly spindly running defender named Bob Murphy.

Working alongside the Bulldogs' pick nine, Aaron Naughton, and Lewis Young, who is still 18, Richards will begin to help replenish a defence that for so long relied on the retired Murphy and Matthew Boyd and the evergreen Dale Morris, who will be 35 next season.

Magpie fans will wish Richards well, taking some solace in the fact the Bulldogs' hierarchy will think of Ron every time Ed's dad turns up.
But he's a Bulldog now and according to Dalrymple the family couldn't be happier for the latest in a long line of footballers.
"They were happy to go anywhere," Dalrymple said.

[Twodogs]

Story about his heritage:

Ed Richards is a Bulldog with Magpie blood running through his veins (http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/afl-draft-ed-richards-is-a-bulldog-with-magpie-blood-running-through-his-veins-20171125-gzssmz.html)


With a crop of red hair like a burning front, Western Bulldogs recruit Ed Richards doesn't exactly resemble his Collingwood premiership-winning grandfather Ron Richards.

But as soon as Western Bulldogs' recruiting manager Simon Dalrymple laid eyes on Ed's dad Kane when he visited the family home, he knew he was dealing with a clan carrying famous Collingwood blood.

https://www.fairfaxstatic.com.au/content/dam/images/g/z/s/t/1/9/image.related.articleLeadwide.620x349.gzssmz.png/1511585227961.jpg

"Kane is a dead ringer for Ron," Dalrymple said.
Ron Richards was a lifelong servant of Collingwood, playing 143 games for the Magpies, including the 1953 premiership alongside his more famous brother Lou, who was the skipper.

Ron lived and breathed Collingwood before and after his playing career ended in 1956, serving as reserves coach, on the match committee, on the board and as a trusted sidekick to a succession of Collingwood coaches including Tom Hafey and Leigh Matthews.

Quieter than 'Louie the Lip', the late Ron Richards, who died in 2013, earned a reputation as a big game player with many claiming he was best on ground playing off a wing in the 1953 triumph.


http://www.smh.com.au/content/dam/images/g/w/0/a/i/v/image.imgtype.articleLeadwide.620x349.png/1494224232756.png

Collingwood flag heroes Ron (left) and Lou Richards. Ron's grandson Ed has joined the Dogs.



Dalrymple, for his part, had become keen on 18-year-old Ed as he watched the youngster grow from a skinny Carey Grammar student to a tearaway Oakleigh Chargers defender in the space of just 18 months as he roared up the draft charts.

"His development during the year was really impressive," Dalrymple said.
But nowhere near as impressive as his football lineage which stretches as far back as 1894.
That's because Ron and Lou also had a famous footballing grandfather on their mum's side.

He was Charlie Pannam, who began with Collingwood VFA from 1894-1896 then became a VFL player with the club from 1897-1907, before spending one season as captain-coach at Richmond when the Tigers joined the league in 1908.

Pannam, who had a Greek heritage but shortened his name from Pannamopoulos, was a footballing pioneer who was inducted into the Australian Football Hall of Fame in 1996.

Along with a three other family members, another Charlie and two Alberts, the Pannam dynasty yielded 939 games, mostly with the Magpies but also with stints at Richmond and South Melbourne.

Now Ed has the chance to add to that games tally after the Bulldogs selected him with pick 16 in the national draft.
While that moment might have caused the hearts of some diehard Magpies to skip a beat, connecting a famous Collingwood name to the Bulldogs is a positive result from an historical perspective.

After all Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge knows better than most what it is like to have a famous grandfather play for the Pies.
His grandfather, Jack, played for Collingwood in the quartet of premierships in the late 1930s but Luke played with the Bulldogs, Melbourne and St Kilda before taking the Bulldogs to the drought-breaking 2016 flag.

The Rose family connection to the Bulldogs has also seen the two clubs compete for the Robert Rose Cup since 2000.
So the Richards link only charges the current running between the two clubs further.

Regardless of his football background, it was Ed's pace and class that made the Bulldogs want him.
"He's composed. He doesn't panic with the ball and he can defend," Dalrymple said.
Eventually, they think Ed might replace a similarly spindly running defender named Bob Murphy.

Working alongside the Bulldogs' pick nine, Aaron Naughton, and Lewis Young, who is still 18, Richards will begin to help replenish a defence that for so long relied on the retired Murphy and Matthew Boyd and the evergreen Dale Morris, who will be 35 next season.

Magpie fans will wish Richards well, taking some solace in the fact the Bulldogs' hierarchy will think of Ron every time Ed's dad turns up.
But he's a Bulldog now and according to Dalrymple the family couldn't be happier for the latest in a long line of footballers.
"They were happy to go anywhere," Dalrymple said.



You can tell from the photo that neither Lou nor Ron were real comfortable with the concept of handballing the ball. ;)

They must have come from the "get ball, have shot at goal" school of football.

[hujsh]

You can tell from the photo that neither Lou nor Ron were real comfortable with the concept of handballing the ball. ;)

They must have come from the "get ball, have shot at goal" school of football.
Looks like he's punching the ball with his knuckles

[bulldogtragic]

From the clubs website:

Imagine sitting in class as a 17-year-old and your English teacher calls you aside to say they were expecting a call from the Western Bulldogs about you.

That was the lot of Ed Richards, the 16th pick in Friday night’s NAB AFL Draft, and the person on the end of the phone was the Bulldogs’ Recruiting Manager Simon Dalrymple.

In a twist of fate, it wasn’t the first time Dalrymple had placed this call either, Richard’s shared the same English teacher as Jack Macrae, so the omens are good so far.

In all the of pre-draft analysis, Richard’s family tree was the lead, which was understandable in that he counts Collingwood greats Ron and Lou Richards among his relatives, but it’ll be the former Oakleigh Chargers’ football that should do the talking from here.

While the Magpies were the team he watched growing up, it’s new teammate Jason Johannisen that he’s been watching closely in more recent times.

“At the start of this year and moving through, I looked up to JJ, just way he takes on the game,” he told westernbulldogs.com.au

“Obviously he had a great 2016 Grand Final, that was a great game to watch. Just how he wanted to attack the ball and win for his team, which was great”.

With the new draftees expected to arrive at VU Whitten Oval on Monday, Richards will have the chance to start learning off of the Bulldogs speedster sooner rather than later.

In any case, he can’t wait to get started.

“I just can’t wait to get stuck into it,” he said.

“You sort of wait for it the whole year, the year sort of drags on a bit, then it finally comes to draft night. And then to get stuck into it on Monday and really have a red hot crack at it over pre-season.”

[GVGjr]

What are the expectations on how many games Richards might be able to achieve in 2018?

I'll go for 6 games probably more on a wing or even a forward flank than in the back line.

[Bulldog Joe]

What are the expectations on how many games Richards might be able to achieve in 2018?

I'll go for 6 games probably more on a wing or even a forward flank than in the back line.

On what we currently know 6 games would be a good result.

A better result would be any games including a flag as per Josh Dunkley's 1st year.

[Twodogs]

On what we currently know 6 games would be a good result.

A better result would be any games including a flag as per Josh Dunkley's 1st year.


Yep, that'd be my preference.

[boydogs]

He might get a few games, HBF one of the easiest positions to start in

[bulldogtragic]

If guys re-discover how to kick effectively inside 50, maybe 3 games.

If the guys don't, and Richards is doing it in the VFL, then up to 7 or 8 on the wing or high HFF. We need players who can kick to advantage going forward and especially inside 50.

[bornadog]

Good luck Sunday on Debut

https://scontent-syd2-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/29597432_2156887614328850_4676148227596389727_n.jpg?_nc_cat= 0&_nc_eui2=v1%3AAeH8r8K7_xDeyHt5RF_hDriJileSQECgwbSwoUb2Hzoevf I6Z5jgychU4bX6wm5BlAOI3SV6OqRiR_0LfNn8No4lVtHWO68va_9Q6Eh8YU I3aQ&oh=cc6f7b55174056b120aac630e4630ab3&oe=5B2B7016

[Twodogs]

Good luck red Ed Richards.

That's some mop of red hair!

[josie]

Good luck Ed! Love the red mop of hair, a really striking colour. I am predicting he will be a bit of an excitement machine for us. Something for fans to look forward to on Sunday, along with a significantly more ferocious attack on the ball and opposition. Got a decent build on him for a young fella based upon above photo.

[bornadog]

20 Ed Richards

Height 185 cm DOB 03-07-1999

Weight 79 kg


My favourite number 20 was Jimmy Edmond. If he is anything like Jimmy he will be a beauty.

[Eastdog]

Good luck Ed!

Hope you have a great debut.

[Bulldog Revolution]

In a team that struggled I thought it was a reasonable start

Seemed confident enough and comfortable at the level - made good decision by hand - didn’t quite hit his kicks as well as I think he can and will but solid start

[Remi Moses]

Tough day to make your debut, but he equipped himself well .
Especially difficult with such inexperience around you

[Mofra]

How good was his second game? Ball use is outstanding.

[Ozza]

The kid has poise. You can see that he is actively trying to do something creative and effective with the footy - he doesn't do the "make it someone else's problem" type of disposal when he is under pressure, but rather takes the time to try and squeeze out the best option.

He is a very good chance to be a long term player.

[Ghost Dog]

If only our coach could remember his name...

[Dry Rot]

Has the same poise and time that I remember from a young Bob Murphy.

[Twodogs]

He looked a bit like Gilbee running out of defence and spearing passes to teammates yesterday. Apart from the redhair of course.

It's the way he lays it out in front for them to run onto it I think.

[The bulldog tragician]

In front of us he did a perfectly timed bump in order to beat his opponent to the ball. That was the “this kid has something special” moment for me - lightly built kids just don’t do that.

[westdog54]

Kept finding myself saying "good boy" over and over again yesterday.

He's a gem.

[Bulldog4life]

A very classy player is young Ed but does the one percenters too. A great draft choice. Thank you Dal.

[Testekill]

It's pretty rare for a running defender to not shy away from the tough stuff. He has a bit of mongrel in him if you ask me

[Twodogs]

Kept finding myself saying "good boy" over and over again yesterday.

He's a gem.

Yep he caused me to slap the seat next to me in delight a few times.

[bornadog]

Yep he caused me to slap the seat next to me in delight a few times.

Poor guy sitting there mustn't have been too happy :D:D:D

[Twodogs]

Poor guy sitting there mustn't have been too happy :D:D:D


I was standing so I had to really lean over the fence in front of me in order to do it. ;)

[Smads57]

Wrapped to have him part of my avatar this season....

[ratsmac]

I love his repeat efforts. Kept trying to scrap for the ball, tackle and harass. His turn of speed is exactly what we need as well. To top it off he is a nice neat kick. Another game like that against Essendon and I'd be extending his contract ASAP.

[bornadog]

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DeBOn09U8AEATj0.jpg

[bulldogtragic]

Looks much better in the tri-colours.

[Remi Moses]

Thought he was a real positive last night

[Bulldog4life]

Best player for us last night in my opinion.

[bulldogtragic]

Thought he was a real positive last night

Yep. He started with the fumbles and then played like a senior player since the senior players around him were doing very little (Wood, JJ, Crozier etc). Broke many of his good personal bests. He's going to be a hell of a player down the track.

[anfo27]

You could see playing against the pies meant something to him. Thought he was very good.

[Twodogs]

You could see playing against the pies meant something to him. Thought he was very good.

We talk a lot about guys like Lippa and Roughy and Wallis and Libba playing with the club they grew up barracking for but I've never really thought before that pretty much everyone else has a first time when they play against the team they grew up following. It'd be a bit weird running around playing against all your heroes. It'd be funny tackling someone to the ground and just as they are getting up and you go to give them that nasty shove back into the ground you realise it's Scott Pendlebury or that Steele Sidebottom just ran past and said something nasty about your mum!


Or that it's your turn to go and you have to run back with the flight of the ball and you are pretty sure that rumbling sound behind you is Brodie Grundy coming in the other direction.

[Topdog]

Could he be a midfielder for us in the future. Good kicking into the f50 is fantastic

[bornadog]

Could he be a midfielder for us in the future. Good kicking into the f50 is fantastic

Could be the speedy outside mid we are looking for.

[jeemak]

Yep. He started with the fumbles and then played like a senior player since the senior players around him were doing very little (Wood, JJ, Crozier etc). Broke many of his good personal bests. He's going to be a hell of a player down the track.

I called him out in the game day thread as probably needing a rest because his touch was off, but he really laid it on when needed and showed character we'll come to love very quickly, because his character is backed by skill and dare.


We talk a lot about guys like Lippa and Roughy and Wallis and Libba playing with the club they grew up barracking for but I've never really thought before that pretty much everyone else has a first time when they play against the team they grew up following. It'd be a bit weird running around playing against all your heroes. It'd be funny tackling someone to the ground and just as they are getting up and you go to give them that nasty shove back into the ground you realise it's Scott Pendlebury or that Steele Sidebottom just ran past and said something nasty about your mum!


Or that it's your turn to go and you have to run back with the flight of the ball and you are pretty sure that rumbling sound behind you is Brodie Grundy coming in the other direction.

It wouldn't really cross their mind in the moment in my view TD, in retrospect definitely. Any decent standard of footy you don't have time for even realising who you're going at unless you have it in the mind to go at them.


Could be the speedy outside mid we are looking for.

Yeah I get why Sedat and others are pissed at us for not drafting midfielders specifically over recent years, but, unless you get the top end draft picks (which as an aside we haven't had between 2015-2017) you draft players who you think can become midfielders (players like Toby McLean). Ed is likely to be one of those.

[bornadog]

Yeah I get why Sedat and others are pissed at us for not drafting midfielders specifically over recent years, but, unless you get the top end draft picks (which as an aside we haven't had between 2015-2017) you draft players who you think can become midfielders (players like Toby McLean). Ed is likely to be one of those.

Completely agree Jeemak, Lippa may be another and Porter could also develop. We need to throw big dollars at an A Grader if we want instant top mid

[jeemak]

Completely agree Jeemak, Lippa may be another and Porter could also develop. We need to throw big dollars at an A Grader if we want instant top mid

I'd be going for Marc Murphy, see if we can get three genuinely good years out of him post 30, and possibly one more. I'd also be throwing the absolute house at Wines, I wanted him and Stringer in their draft year, now Stringer is gone I want him to complement Macrae.

I'd also throw a lot of money at Robbie Gray.

[ratsmac]

I'd be going for Marc Murphy, see if we can get three genuinely good years out of him post 30, and possibly one more. I'd also be throwing the absolute house at Wines, I wanted him and Stringer in their draft year, now Stringer is gone I want him to complement Macrae.

I'd also throw a lot of money at Robbie Gray.

You sound like you have plenty of money :D

Murphy is too old. Great player but turns 31 in July.

Wines is a big yes please but what would he cost?

Is Robby Gray even gettable? I would've thought Port would make sure he's locked away on a long term deal.

I'd have a sneaky crack at Wingard while we're at it.

[Mofra]

Yeah I get why Sedat and others are pissed at us for not drafting midfielders specifically over recent years, but, unless you get the top end draft picks (which as an aside we haven't had between 2015-2017) you draft players who you think can become midfielders (players like Toby McLean). Ed is likely to be one of those.
A lot of people were harsh on Lipinski from Friday's game, I was fairly happy with it. You could see his style will translate pretty well from forward to midfield and he clearly has a natural football brain. He should develop into someone who can rotate through the centre in time and hopefully he'll be best 22 come next year. We can certainly use someone like him who is excellent by foot. I see a bit of Gia in the way he plays.

[Mofra]

I'd have a sneaky crack at Wingard while we're at it.
I'd think Wingard is the least gettable of the lot - GWS overlooked him with their first 5 picks that draft because he would be off to SA as soon as his two years were up. Can't see him leaving the state.

[bornadog]

By golly, a Richards playing for the Doggies (https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/by-golly-a-richards-playing-for-the-doggies-20180524-p4zhav.html)


In any other time Ed Richards would be playing for Collingwood on Friday night, not against them.
Playing for Collingwood was the family business. Ed was born into it.

But there is no grandfather-son rule, there is no scion rule that would permit Ed Richards to carry the family torch in black and white.

The Richards-Pannam families are as fundamental to Collingwood as black and white stripes. They span the history of the club for a hundred years from the first game though to the 1990 premiership side.

From his grandparent to his great uncles and his great-great-grand father across five generations, the Richards and Pannams played about 1000 games of VFL football for Collingwood. The patriarch Charlie Pannam snr played for Collingwood in 1894 when it was in the VFA and then in the club’s first game in the new VFL.

Charlie Pannam snr was Ron Richards’ grandfather. Ron’s uncles played for Collingwood too. When Ron and Lou were good enough to ply vFL there was only one club for them. It was out of their hands. Ironically now it was also of Ed’s hands who he would play for – it was the draft that would decide, not family history.

Ron knew Ed had it. "He’s got something," he told Ed’s dad, Kane, as they watched him play juniors.
"Ron used to go to Ed's games all the time until he got a bit ill and the cold would get to him," Kane said.

"Dad could spot good young players anywhere. He said to me, 'Make sure he follows through with it because he has got something'. Ed was only nine or 10 at that stage, but Ron could see it."

Ron Richards did everything at Collingwood. He came to the club as a player, the younger brother of Lou, but made his own mark. He was voted their best player in the finals and won a flag as a player alongside Lou in 1953.

He coached the under 19s and the reserves for years and even filled in as senior coach for two matches. He was the chairman of selectors and Leigh Matthews assistant coach in 1990 when they won the flag. He worked for Collingwood in some capacity for six decades.

He was the talkative but never quoted backroom man. Lou was the front man – football's first and ultimate showman.
Ronnie was out of Collingwood by the time Ed was along so Ed didn't really know that side of him.

"As a junior I didn't know much about it but then kids moved around in teams and new kids came in and they knew me and I became aware the family was prominent in football, but to me he was just Poppa."

Going through the system Ed knew that the Magpies had no tie to him so he just aimed to make it as a footballer, not a Collingwood player.

"Every player grows up dreaming of playing for he club they barrack for and I was no different, I had the family history too, but it was always more unlikely than likely it would be at Collingwood. I just wanted to focus on myself then and be good enough to play. I couldn't be happier. I am at a great club," Ed said.

The idea that Ed the Grndson of this family that is as intrinsically Collingwood as the Magpie itself, would play somewhere else breaks the heart of the club's own Ed, president Eddie McGuire.

“We would love to have him. It doesn’t feel right to me that he is not at Collingwood. In these days when 25 per cent of the kids in the draft will go to clubs through zones and academies the grandson of probably the strongest family tie in the history of the AFL-VFL doesn’t go to that club. [It] doesn't feel right,” McGuire said.

“I like seeing families in football, I would like to see a brothers rule where brothers play together – I think the Brayshaws should all be playing together at North where their dad was on the board and their uncle was president. We saw Tom Phillips and his brother Ed playing against one another last week.

“At the moment the way the rules are if my sons were good enough to be drafted they couldn’t go to Collingwood despite 20 years as unpaid president but if I was in the draft I’d be in a zone to a club because my dad is Irish and my mum Scottish. That's the way it is.”

Collingwood could have drafted Richards last year with their first pick but they chose Jayden Stephenson. Pick six was a little too high in the draft for him.

The Bulldogs were thrilled. Their then recruiter Simon Dalrymple, now at Sydney Swans, liked Richards enough that after taking Aaron Naughton at 9 they regarded Richards the next best talent. They were chuffed that he was still there when hey had their next crack at 16.

Kane sees his dad in Ed. “He has a lot of Ronnie about him,” he said. Though he thinks football has to thank his wife, Carey, for Ed making it as a footballer, not the Richards family.

At 16 Ed was no good thing to make it. He was too short.
“He had the Richards height!” Kane said. “Then he shot up, so he has his mum’s side to thank for that."

He also has his mum's side to thank for the red hair – a great aunt had bright red hair like Ed's. He's a throwback to her. And to the four Charlies and Albies and to Lou and Ron.

"Where Ed is now and how well he is going is down to him. It’s about Ed’s story now not Collingwood.”

PANNAM-RICHARDS DYNASTY

Charlie Pannam snr
229 games for Collingwood
111 goals
League leading goal kicker (1905)
2 premierships (1902, 1903)
Collingwood captain (1905)
Collingwood Hall of Fame

Albert Pannam
Charlie’s younger brother
28 games (1907- 09)

Charlie Pannam jr
Charlie snr’s son and the first father-son in Collingwood history
97 games for Collingwood
2 premierships (1917, 1919)

Alby Pannam
Charlie snr’s son
181 games for Collingwood
453 goals
Collingwood Captain (1945)
2 premierships (1935, 36)
Copeland Trophy (1942)
Collingwood Hall of fame

Lou Richards
Charles and Alby’s nephew, Ron’s older brother
250 games for Collingwood
423 goals
1 premiership (1953)
Collingwood captain (1952-55)
Collingwood Hall of Fame

Ron Richards
Charles and Alby’s nephew, Lou’s younger brother
143 games for Collingwood
1 premiership (1953)
Collingwood Under 19s coach, reserves coach, senior coach
Collingwood Hall of Fame

Ed Richards
Grandson of Ron, great-great-grandson of Charlie Pannam snr
9th game for Western Bulldogs this week

[G-Mo77]

One of the very few, if not the only positive on Friday night. Well done young man!

[ratsmac]

I almost feel bad he plays with us and not Collingwood after reading that...almost, but at the same time I love that he doesn't play for them and he does us.

[Twodogs]

I almost feel bad he plays with us and not Collingwood after reading that...almost, but at the same time I love that he doesn't play for them and he does us.


The Collingwood connection is revenge for Ben Reid. I saw most of Bruce's games and Ben had spent 16 of his 18 years F/S qualified with us. They changed the qualification two years before his draft.

Then again if they offered us an 18 yo Ben Reid for Ed Richards right now I'd say "thanks, but Ed is a bulldog now"

[bulldogtragic]

1. Ed's work as a rebounding defender is very good.
2. Ed's work on the wing, streaming forward and kicking inside 50 is very good. 5 goal assists this year.
3. Ed's work up forward is very good. 7.4 so far this year, with two hauls of three goals (straight) playing as a forward.

As a serious question of his development, where should Bevo play him and develop him. I'm not sure playing him everywhere, despite his near Bontempelli like ability to play anywhere, is the best strategy. So where's his best position?

[azabob]

For me wing / forward of the ball. He just makes things happen.

[Remi Moses]

Agree with two dogs
We had to endure the pain of Bruce Reid
We deserved Ben and Sam

[Twodogs]

Agree with two dogs
We had to endure the pain of Bruce Reid
We deserved Ben and Sam

Yep Little Ed is our recompense. For Butch Edwards too.

[boydogs]

For me wing / forward of the ball. He just makes things happen.

Agree, Bailey Dale's role

[DOG GOD]

Yep, wing/ half forward....his brilliant run and disposal will give us plenty of goals to come.

[Twodogs]

After last night wing/half forward for sure. His goal kicking nous is invaluable and his running and creativity between the arcs reminds me a little bit of Doug Hawkins. Hawk always had an eye for a goal but if someone was in better position Doug would plant it on their chest from anywhere on the ground. Red Ed has that some ability to sum up the pass/shot for goal situation really quickly and carry it out that the Hawk (and comparing a player to Doug Hawkins is not something I do lightly, especially a first year player) had.

Hawkins was a better overhead mark but Ed would leave Doug standing in the blocks in a sprint, he is much quicker. I'd love to see Richards left on a wing for the rest of the season.

[azabob]

The goal in the last which he kicked off the ground he should've taken the mark. The way he used his body in the marking contest was extrememly impressive.

[Testekill]

We're going to be sitting pretty with him on one wing and Lipinski on the other.

[westdog54]

The goal in the last which he kicked off the ground he should've taken the mark. The way he used his body in the marking contest was extrememly impressive.


https://www.facebook.com/Western.Bulldogs/videos/10156414477742487/

This passage of play is rolled gold from start to finish.

The one on one strip and bullet handball from the Bont, great overlap running and a perfectly placed kick by McLean, and Richards providing some sauce and a cherry on top.

[bornadog]

https://www.facebook.com/Western.Bulldogs/videos/10156414477742487/

This passage of play is rolled gold from start to finish.

The one on one strip and bullet handball from the Bont, great overlap running and a perfectly placed kick by McLean, and Richards providing some sauce and a cherry on top.

Three Geelong players can only watch it roll through.

How good was The Bont's handball.

[westdog54]

Three Geelong players can only watch it roll through.

How good was The Bont's handball.

The extra treat is watching GAj gently amble after Toby Mac as he breaks the line.

[bulldogtragic]

After this round:

Ranked 9th among rising stars in Total Goal Assists
Ranked 5th among rising stars in Total Kicks
Ranked 8th among rising stars in Total Disposals
Ranked 9th among rising stars in Total Tackles
Ranked 6th among rising stars in Total Supercoach Score
Ranked 10th among rising stars in Total AFL Fantasy Score
Ranked 6th among rising stars in Total Contested Possessions
Ranked 6th among rising stars in Total Clangers
Ranked 8th among rising stars in Total Clearances
Ranked 6th among rising stars in Total Rebound 50s
Ranked 8th among rising stars in Total One Percenters
Ranked 1st among rising stars in Total Bounces
Ranked 10th among rising stars in Total Time On Ground %
Ranked 10th among rising stars in Total Centre Clearances
Ranked 9th among rising stars in Total Stoppage Clearances
Ranked 7th among rising stars in Total Metres Gained
Ranked 9th among rising stars in Total Turnovers
Ranked 7th among rising stars in Total Intercepts
Ranked 8th among rising stars in SuperCoach Score per game
Ranked 9th among rising stars in kicks per game
Ranked 3rd among rising stars in bounces per game per game

[boydogs]

I don't think season-long rankings do him justice, his last month is what brings him into calculations

[Twodogs]

Ed's footy over the last month has been as good as Bontempelli's was when he first hit the scene. Apart from Brian Royal and Steve Wallis in 1983 and the freakish 16 yo Chris Grant in 1990 and the Bont I can't remember a more accomplished debuts than Ed's.

[Mofra]

Ed's footy over the last month has been as good as Bontempelli's was when he first hit the scene. Apart from Brian Royal and Steve Wallis in 1983 and the freakish 16 yo Chris Grant in 1990 and the Bont I can't remember a more accomplished debuts than Ed's.
Georgiades

*runs*

[Twodogs]

Georgiades

*runs*


There are plenty who had great debuts, Ross Christensen, Kieran Macguiness, even Premiership hero Jason Tutt had a debut against Port Adelaide where the ball followed him around. I was more meaning coming into the side and making a difference with a sustained burst of form.

[bornadog]

Ed is on Bob's Freedom in a Cage Podcast released today.

Details here (http://www.westernbulldogs.com.au/news/2018-07-05/freedom-in-a-cage-episode-15-ed-richards)

[Mofra]

Ed is on Bob's Freedom in a Cage Podcast released today.

Details here (http://www.westernbulldogs.com.au/news/2018-07-05/freedom-in-a-cage-episode-15-ed-richards)
Interesting when Ed said last year at school footy he kicked 3 goals 18 for the year!

[Twodogs]

Interesting when Ed said last year at school footy he kicked 3 goals 18 for the year!


Biased dads goal umpiring probably.

[bornadog]

UNSUNG HEROES — ROUND 21 (http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/unsung-heroes-round-21-2/)
Western Bulldogs: Ed Richards


The stats may not depict his influence, but Ed Richards’ bravery with ball in hand was pivotal to the Bulldogs’ second-half comeback.

The first-year product only kicked the ball three times out of his 17 disposals, but his dash off half-back broke the game open when the Dogs started their unlikely comeback.

[The bulldog tragician]

UNSUNG HEROES — ROUND 21 (http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/unsung-heroes-round-21-2/)
Western Bulldogs: Ed Richards


The stats may not depict his influence, but Ed Richards’ bravery with ball in hand was pivotal to the Bulldogs’ second-half comeback.

The first-year product only kicked the ball three times out of his 17 disposals, but his dash off half-back broke the game open when the Dogs started their unlikely comeback.

After looking fatigued the past few weeks Little Red had spark and dash. He will be a joy to watch over the next few years. (Get your mitts off him Eddie, he’s ours.)

[bulldogtragic]

Anyone have any guesses where his great kicking from last year has gone? I don't think kicking skills fall under 'second year blues', so I'm confused how his amazing foot skills have seemingly abandoned him thus far.

[bornadog]

Anyone have any guesses where his great kicking from last year has gone? I don't think kicking skills fall under 'second year blues', so I'm confused how his amazing foot skills have seemingly abandoned him thus far.

Maybe I am watching a different game, but last night he ran at 75%DE and zero clangers. Personally, I don't see an issue.

[jeemak]

Anyone have any guesses where his great kicking from last year has gone? I don't think kicking skills fall under 'second year blues', so I'm confused how his amazing foot skills have seemingly abandoned him thus far.

He had one excellent switch yesterday, but has largely been ineffective by foot this year. Not sure if he is playing more midfield time and that's fatiguing him.

I suspect we don't practice our kicking under pressure enough and this is why it breaks down on game day. But I don't watch training so can't really say.

I'm making an assumption that professional players who practice kicking in the right way get better, and professional players who don't stagnate or get worse. We're seeing the latter, it's the only conclusion I can come to.

[bulldogtragic]

He had one excellent switch yesterday, but has largely been ineffective by foot this year. Not sure if he is playing more midfield time and that's fatiguing him.

I suspect we don't practice our kicking under pressure enough and this is why it breaks down on game day. But I don't watch training so can't really say. Players who practice kicking in the right way get better. Players who don't stagnate or get worse. We're seeing the latter, it's the only conclusion I can come to.

Appreciate the insights Mr J, I've personally seen a decline in his kicking because he was a standout last year. And I couldn't conceptualise how he could fall back into the pack of mediocre kicks. Stats can say one thing, but watching the games and seeing the decline says another. I wonder since it was a learned skill, whether it's a matter of additional remedial training, or whether it's a VFL stint thing?

[DOG GOD]

It might also be the case of where he is playing BT. On a half back flank, he can use his run and can pinpoint more just as Daniel has been doing. Mostly, he’s running in straight lines.

When he’s been playing fwd, he’s obviously running to the ball, getting the ball, then having to either stop, swivel, look around, non existent fwd line, or so congested, he’s in a hurry to hit up a target. A lot of his kicks are only going like 20-30 metres, whereas last year in defence, he was pinpointing more 40+ metres kicks, with a more fluent kicking style. Just my opinion.

[Twodogs]

Anyone have any guesses where his great kicking from last year has gone? I don't think kicking skills fall under 'second year blues', so I'm confused how his amazing foot skills have seemingly abandoned him thus far.

My theory is he is getting bad coaching/advice on how to improve his kicking? EVERY player's kicking skills have gone backwards amd it isn't just since Bevo arrived, it goes back to the latter days of Eade. The last time I can remember our players being adequate kicks was in Rocket's first few years, since then its been a pig's breakfast.

[boydogs]

Richards has delivered inside 50 really well which is why I have wanted him to stay in the side despite not getting involved much

[hujsh]

His kicking isn't worse IMO. He goes for the killer pass which sometimes doesn't come off. Perhaps you're just remembering the good ones from last year and have come to expect that from him because he certainly grubbed his share last year.

[bornadog]

His kicking isn't worse IMO. He goes for the killer pass which sometimes doesn't come off. Perhaps you're just remembering the good ones from last year and have come to expect that from him because he certainly grubbed his share last year.

I can't see any difference either.

[FrediKanoute]

I've resisted the urge to call for Richard's head. I think he is better in the side than out. Maybe the time will come when someone in the Footscray side is banging down the door to take his place. Maybe Dale/Lippa, but I think he gets another week or 2.

[GVGjr]

I've resisted the urge to call for Richard's head. I think he is better in the side than out. Maybe the time will come when someone in the Footscray side is banging down the door to take his place. Maybe Dale/Lippa, but I think he gets another week or 2.
He's adjusting to a different role and I'm sure he will get there but so far he isn't quite having the same impact as last season.
He's still getting the ball but things like how a couple of weeks back he ran into an open goal and missed the lot by spraying the kick are taking the shine off his game. I'd be sticking with him for the time being as he has the pace and skill attributes we need

His decision making and skill level was so noticeable last year he probably has a higher level of expectation placed on him.

[Doc26]

We see Ed’s ceiling as quite high, which only in his second year, reasonably he hasn’t reached. He offers leg speed, which we seriously are lacking in, and whilst he maybe a bit down on where we might’ve hoped he would’ve progressed to early in season 2, he’s not where our main problems lie. I’d only consider managing him through the season, not dropping him per se.

[bornadog]

We see Ed’s ceiling as quite high, which only in his second year, reasonably he hasn’t reached. He offers leg speed, which we seriously are lacking in, and whilst he maybe a bit down on where we might’ve hoped he would’ve progressed to early in season 2, he’s not where our main problems lie. I’d only consider managing him through the season, not dropping him per se.

He is still only 19 years old and looking like he will play for a long time. I am not expecting too much from him.

[Mofra]

We see Ed’s ceiling as quite high, which only in his second year, reasonably he hasn’t reached. He offers leg speed, which we seriously are lacking in, and whilst he maybe a bit down on where we might’ve hoped he would’ve progressed to early in season 2, he’s not where our main problems lie. I’d only consider managing him through the season, not dropping him per se.
I'm not sure we've playing him to his strengths. In the forward line he can use his smarts but his other forte is run and carry. I'd play him higher up the ground - I like his potential as a wingman.

[GVGjr]

Where is Ed Richards at for the 2020 season?

He's already played 41 senior games in his two seasons with us but for some reason I'm not sure he is seen by the MC as a lot more than a spare parts player. Perhaps that is a harsh assessment but you can probably get my point.

Richards had a terrific debut season where he played mainly as a defender but this year he shuffled between midfield and forward duties and seemed to start games on the bench a significant number of times.

A return to the back line seems a long way off now given the options we have and I think he needs to be established on the opposite wing to Lachie Hunter.

Richards is now approaching 50 games of senior football and he should be primed for a big season in 2020.
He's got great skills and pace although his goal kicking accuracy wasn't flash and his possession count needs to lift if he is played more in the midfield

I'm genuinely looking forward to seeing if he can develop further

[Bulldog Joe]

Richards clearly has talent, but he also has a lot of competition for a spot in the 22.

His pace is something we need. However he needs a big year just to maintain a spot.

[Torpedo]

Needs to improve his kicking though, when he has the afterburners on. Sprays too many kicks either for goal or to forwards. Has many good attributes and his ground speed stands out in our midfield group. Winger for mine and he should, in his 3rd full season, start to lower his eyes more often and improve his delivery to our forwards. If he does, he will be a valuable weapon.

[jeemak]

Like a lot of players adapting to the level he struggles with production forward of centre, and seems much more comfortable behind the footy.

This will become easier for him as his tank improves, right now he's probably spending his tickets and more concerned with getting back and not letting the team down rather than pushing forward to create an option. I want him on the wing or at half forward, we need quick players with penetrating kicks delivering to our tall forwards one out, and he's a guy who can do that.

[GVGjr]

Like a lot of players adapting to the level he struggles with production forward of centre, and seems much more comfortable behind the footy.

This will become easier for him as his tank improves, right now he's probably spending his tickets and more concerned with getting back and not letting the team down rather than pushing forward to create an option. I want him on the wing or at half forward, we need quick players with penetrating kicks delivering to our tall forwards one out, and he's a guy who can do that.

I think that sums up his challenges perfectly. Wing and half forward are his positions going forward and if he can improve his kicking skills including his goal kicking he will be a great player for us.
We have a number of emerging players on our list and Richards offers us a point of difference with his pace

[Nuggety Back Pocket]

Where is Ed Richards at for the 2020 season?

He's already played 41 senior games in his two seasons with us but for some reason I'm not sure he is seen by the MC as a lot more than a spare parts player. Perhaps that is a harsh assessment but you can probably get my point.

Richards had a terrific debut season where he played mainly as a defender but this year he shuffled between midfield and forward duties and seemed to start games on the bench a significant number of times.

A return to the back line seems a long way off now given the options we have and I think he needs to be established on the opposite wing to Lachie Hunter.

Richards is now approaching 50 games of senior football and he should be primed for a big season in 2020.
He's got great skills and pace although his goal kicking accuracy wasn't flash and his possession count needs to lift if he is played more in the midfield

I'm genuinely looking forward to seeing if he can develop further
Ed looked terrific in his first season as a defender. Struggled to adjust in his second year which is not unusual for a second year player. Good enough to become a regular particularly given his pace which we lack.

[AshMac]

he really did seem to lose that composure and kicking accuracy he had in his first year. I do have a feeling he can be a game winner and with another preseason of fitness and more time to build his composure in pressure his raw talent and speed can shine.

So much potential.

[Bulldog Revolution]

A return to the back line seems a long way off now given the options we have and I think he needs to be established on the opposite wing to Lachie Hunter.



I'd like to see Richards and Lipinski interchanging/rotating through that wing/half forward spots - Richards speed and use give him a chance to impact the game in less touches than others, but he does need to accumulate more also.

I think youve outlined the challenges for him, and I'd back him in to be ready to take on the challenge.

[Mofra]

I really, really prefer him behind the ball. I know we need help on the second wing but he's either going to be a 'hopefully ok' wingman or an excellent rebounder. Suckling isn't going to play forever, and Wood is getting long in the tooth and with his hammies I can't see him playing well into his 30s.

[AshMac]

I'd like to see Richards and Lipinski interchanging/rotating through that wing/half forward spots - Richards speed and use give him a chance to impact the game in less touches than others, but he does need to accumulate more also.

I think youve outlined the challenges for him, and I'd back him in to be ready to take on the challenge.

Lipinski is an interesting one. I’d like to see him as a perm high half forward who only rotates through the middle when we need it.

[GVGjr]

Despite racking up an impressive 41 senior games in his 2 years with us I wonder if 2020 will be a bit more challenging for Richards?

In his first season he was mainly used as a defender and looked right at home but with our gun coach always looking for versatility in players and with a surplus of mid sized defenders in 2019 Richards was used more as a small forward and in the midfield and I think it's fair to say that he had some challenges with that. That's all fine though because most young players will experience some leaner times early in their career.

Going into the 2020 season it seems Richards will need to establish himself in the midfield as available spots up forward are going to be quite scarce but a role in the midfield should suit him perfectly. I've said it before but his best position might be on the opposite wing to Hunter.

Much like in his debut season in 2018 I think Richards best game in the 2019 season was against Collingwood and as the Pies are our our first round opponent this year Richards needs to be in our best 22 come round one, well at least that is my fuzzy logic :)

What do you see as the main challenge for Richards this year? Can he continue to be a regular senior player and what does he need to improve on?

I'm a big fan of Richards but this might be a testing challenge for him.

[The Underdog]

Despite racking up an impressive 41 senior games in his 2 years with us I wonder if 2020 will be a bit more challenging for Richards?

In his first season he was mainly used as a defender and looked right at home but with our gun coach always looking for versatility in players and with a surplus of mid sized defenders in 2019 Richards was used more as a small forward and in the midfield and I think it's fair to say that he had some challenges with that. That's all fine though because most young players will experience some leaner times early in their career.

Going into the 2020 season it seems Richards will need to establish himself in the midfield as available spots up forward are going to be quite scarce but a role in the midfield should suit him perfectly. I've said it before but his best position might be on the opposite wing to Hunter.

Much like in his debut season in 2018 I think Richards best game in the 2019 season was against Collingwood and as the Pies are our our first round opponent this year Richards needs to be in our best 22 come round one, well at least that is my fuzzy logic :)

What do you see as the main challenge for Richards this year? Can he continue to be a regular senior player and what does he need to improve on?

I'm a big fan of Richards but this might be a testing challenge for him.

He definitely has the capacity to be top 22. His pace and skill by foot are both great assets, but he does play a position where we have a surplus of talent. As you say, I think ideally he plays the opposite wing to Hunter. I have to say I haven't taken great notice of his defensive running so not sure where he sits there, but he certainly can be an offensive threat.
He's getting heat for a lesser 2nd year but I think a lot of people want all players to have a linear progression and it just doesn't happen that often. Players often drop back a little in season 2 for whatever reason. He did also have some moments in his first season where he was moved forward and was effective, so I'm not sure the drop off can be totally put down to him being played out of position. But I'm a big believer in Ed, I think if he can consistently find the football, he can be a big weapon in 2020.

[Hotdog60]

He could be a JJ clone has some dash and maybe better evasive skills than JJ. So I see him off the half back flank but fitting him in is the problem.
Could you alternate him and JJ off the bench and let them run all day. Although this may not work with the rotations cap in place.
We appear to be in a very good place at the moment with trying to find spots for players.

[Mofra]

Has pace and footskills - that sets him apart from many of our best 22 locks.

I still have question marks over his production forward of the ball. He plays 'ok' on a wing and has his moments as a forward, but he is still clearly better suited to a role behind the ball where we have a surplus of talent.
Perhaps he starts there for a round or two (while Duryea recovers) which gets his confidence up, then becomes one of those second wing rotations.

[GVGjr]

Richards has now completed 3 seasons with us and despite playing 17 of 18 games for us this year he really hasn't progressed like I think many of us thought he would have. Mofra pointed our before the season got underway that he seems to be better if he was to be played as a defender and I think his best game for us this year as when he was played in the back line

So after 58 games with us is Richards likely to become the type of footballer many of us thought he could be after a highly encouraging first season or is he more likely to be someone who fills in for us in a variety of midfield and forward positions?

His season stats were not impressive for a midfielder/forward averaging just under 11 possessions a game albeit in reduced length of games.
I wonder if his concussion injury earlier in the year had a lingering impact with him

[hujsh]

I think if we swapped him with Wood (Wood out of the side) we'd have a better balance. He looked good back there and that second linebreaking option besides JJ would be helpful.

[EasternWest]

Nowhere near becoming the player he looked like he might, but he's tough and willing and I remain hopeful.

[Happy Days]

I love Ed and really think he's got a high level of ability, but the fact of the matter is that he's gone backwards in consecutive seasons now. Of course he'd look better on a half back flank, literally every player does.

He has the skills and some of the traits to make it as a flanker or a winger, but he also doesn't get the ball without having it given to him nor does he make himself dangerous in space. And there is absolutely no excuse for a player so skillful to miss as many targets as he does.

In sum, I am officially concerned.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

I have big concerns. He can't find the ball and his disposal is poor.

Either he makes it as a half back/wing or he doesn't make it IMO.

I'd entertain what offers we could get for him though I do like his pace and ability in 1-v-1s.

[Vred]

Word on the street is his not happy with where his being played and is looking to swap clubs to somewhere that will play him in his desired position, atleast, according to the trade threads on bigfooty.

[Rocket Science]

When I gaze with envy upon Port's ability to develop and integrate their kids as best-22 types who can positively influence games, then look back at ours before getting the shits, I'm afraid Ed's Exhibit A.

There's a Heeney-esque star somewhere in there I reckon, but have zero faith he'll get near it under our tutelage and lest we fix that his best value to us may well be as bait.

[dog town]

When I gaze with envy upon Port's ability to develop and integrate their kids a-22 types who can positively influence games, then look back at ours before getting the shits, I'm afraid Ed's Exhibit A.

There's a Heeney-esque star somewhere in there I reckon, but have zero faith he'll get near it under our tutelage and lest we fix that his best value to us may well be as bait. I have watched our coaches get blamed for many things I disagree with this week on several threads but I can’t let this one slide.

Richards just isn’t very good at this stage and HE needs to address some major flaws in his game. Of course our development should be doing this as well but you can guarantee these parts of his game are being worked on.

He needs to not pick and choose when he bodylines the ball and he needs to use the ball with more composure. The tendency to drop his kicks short or shank kicks at full pace was there when we drafted him.

Comparing him to Duursma, Rozee and Butters who were taken in a stronger draft shouldn’t reflect poorly on our coaches. If it does then you would have to give them credit for Smith, Naughton and Dunkley?

The only thing I will say is that he is far better suited to half back or even around the ball than a wing or forward. Not sure you can hold this against the coaching team though because this applies to most players and we can’t play them all there.

[DOG GOD]

If Ed’s desired position is half back, then why the need to recruit an abundance of half back types. This only causes Ed and the like to have to play wing/half forward to get a game and they aren’t being developed in their best suited role.

[GVGjr]

I have watched our coaches get blamed for many things I disagree with this week on several threads but I can’t let this one slide.

Richards just isn’t very good at this stage and HE needs to address some major flaws in his game. Of course our development should be doing this as well but you can guarantee these parts of his game are being worked on.



I think many of us can see the upside and the potential in his game plus some flaws as well so given all that why has he been as good as an automatic selection each week in what wasn't a good season for him?

[comrade]

I think many of us can see the upside and the potential in his game plus some flaws as well so given all that why has he been as good as an automatic selection each week in what wasn't a good season for him?

Exactly. His flaws are obvious yet he played all year, that is coaching.

[GVGjr]

Exactly. His flaws are obvious yet he played all year, that is coaching.

12 months ago, the consensus here was that we had struck the right balance in the playing list with our mids, KP (we recruited KP bookends) and ruck mix etc however, given Richards was played through the season does that now question the depth and quality of our playing list?

[Danjul]

I have watched our coaches get blamed for many things I disagree with this week on several threads but I can’t let this one slide.

Richards just isn’t very good at this stage and HE needs to address some major flaws in his game. Of course our development should be doing this as well but you can guarantee these parts of his game are being worked on.

ft shouldn’t reflect poorly on our coaches. If it does then you would have to give them credit for Smith, Naughton and Dunkley?

Not sure you can hold this against the coaching team though because this applies to most players and we can’t play them all there.

Interesting that Richards, Naughton and Dunkley all come together here.

In the elimination final Dunkley had his equal worst number of possessions for the season. He equaled the 13 he got when playing second ruck against the Cats Another close loss, where rucking took him away from his natural game.

Naughton had 2 possessions to 3/4 time ( because Bruce was simply crashing the contests?) and Richards with 7 possessions was also very close to his worst game for the season. At least 3 others had their season worst number of disposals in that game.

And still they lost by less than a goal. St Kilda wasn’t very good. Who does that fiasco reflect poorly on?

[Rocket Science]

12 months ago, the consensus here was that we had struck the right balance in the playing list with our mids, KP (we recruited KP bookends) and ruck mix etc however, given Richards was played through the season does that now question the depth and quality of our playing list?

Precisely. It's reasonable to assert Richards (and a gaggle of others) mightn't have been doing enough to retain their spots but we can only be as ruthless as the calibre of depth we can confidently call upon.

Not to mention dropping blokes this season was doubly problematic given no reserves tier competition.

Still, if you spell Richards a spell, who comes in?

[GVGjr]

Precisely. It's reasonable to assert Richards (and a gaggle of others) mightn't have been doing enough to retain their spots but we can only be as ruthless as the calibre of depth we can confidently call upon.

Not to mention dropping blokes this season was doubly problematic given no reserves tier competition.

Still, if you spell Richards a spell, who comes in?

Based on the ones that did come in they were mainly rookies.

I just struggle with the concept of having all the playing list up in the Hub and we couldn't locate a couple of players to replace the ones out of form. 4 games between Trengove Schache and Lewis Young, Hayes played just a couple of games and West, Greene, Lynch, Cavarra sparingly used if at all and Dale and Lipinski cycling in and out.

Given we had a close look at the group this year and obviously didn't rate a high number of them I will be interested to see who we shop around and let go from the group.

[jeemak]

Interesting that Richards, Naughton and Dunkley all come together here.

In the elimination final Dunkley had his equal worst number of possessions for the season. He equaled the 13 he got when playing second ruck against the Cats Another close loss, where rucking took him away from his natural game.

Naughton had 2 possessions to 3/4 time ( because Bruce was simply crashing the contests?) and Richards with 7 possessions was also very close to his worst game for the season. At least 3 others had their season worst number of disposals in that game.

And still they lost by less than a goal. St Kilda wasn’t very good. Who does that fiasco reflect poorly on?

The players who played poorly by their own standards?

[GVGjr]

The players who played poorly by their own standards?

100%, we just need to make sure there is a valid reason why they aren't performing to their ability

[jeemak]

Specifically on Richards I'd view his output differently if he tidied up his kicking to the extent I think most of us believe he can with some concentration and attention to detail.

He does run hard and does try to run at the defence which is exactly what we need, though without using the ball well enough to hurt with the limited touches he is getting at present he's not effective enough. I wanted him spelled throughout the year because there's actually some merit in dropping players for repeated execution issues, but it didn't happen which tells me he has to be doing a body of things without the ball that I can't see that the coaches like in order to have kept his place.

Time is definitely on his side and I would not be moving him on until given the chance to mature. However, I would like to see some improvement in execution and production pretty quickly to keep the faith.

[GVGjr]

Time is definitely on his side and I would not be moving him on until given the chance to mature. However, I would like to see some improvement in execution and production pretty quickly to keep the faith.
We aren't likely to trade any player who is playing each week unless someone else is willing to pay overs and in the case of Richards that might be well overs.

[Rocket Science]

Based on the ones that did come in they were mainly rookies.

I just struggle with the concept of having all the playing list up in the Hub and we couldn't locate a couple of players to replace the ones out of form. 4 games between Trengove Schache and Lewis Young, Hayes played just a couple of games and West, Greene, Lynch, Cavarra sparingly used if at all and Dale and Lipinski cycling in and out.

Given we had a close look at the group this year and obviously didn't rate a high number of them I will be interested to see who we shop around and let go from the group.

Indeed, but you've forgotten one ... That the MC figured at one point 'hey, let's have another look at Billy' suggests a bit about the level of competition for spots.

[1eyedog]

I think many of us can see the upside and the potential in his game plus some flaws as well so given all that why has he been as good as an automatic selection each week in what wasn't a good season for him?

Perceived ceiling and our desire to fast-track it.

[GVGjr]

Perceived ceiling and our desire to fast-track it.

3 or 4 less games I don't think would have slowed down his development

He's another required player

[Mofra]

12 months ago, the consensus here was that we had struck the right balance in the playing list with our mids, KP (we recruited KP bookends) and ruck mix etc however, given Richards was played through the season does that now question the depth and quality of our playing list?
Bailey Williams wasn't a lock in our best 22 12 months ago.
It seems Ed Richards and JJ are vying for the same position in the back half, the guy who runs the ball from defence and takes an opposition small. Ed's tougher than JJ but JJ has better agility.

[SquirrelGrip]

Bailey Williams wasn't a lock in our best 22 12 months ago.
It seems Ed Richards and JJ are vying for the same position in the back half, the guy who runs the ball from defence and takes an opposition small. Ed's tougher than JJ but JJ has better agility.

Moving Caleb up field allows us then to have Richards in defence with JJ. Ed has so much upside.

[1eyedog]

Moving Caleb up field allows us then to have Richards in defence with JJ. Ed has so much upside.

But he just won AA and our BF from the backline?

[SquirrelGrip]

But he just won AA and our BF from the backline?

Yes, and he is such an offensive threat that let's use him where he can get more of it and enter the forward 50.

[Axe Man]

Yes, and he is such an offensive threat that let's use him where he can get more of it and enter the forward 50.

Half Back/Back Pocket is the easiest position on the ground to get a kick, he's not getting more of it moving up the ground. In fact half forward is just about the hardest position on the ground to get the ball.

I'm sure Daniel would be useful up the ground but I don't think he's a wingman and he will struggle to have nearly the same influence at half forward. There is also no way Richards is going to come close to replicating Caleb's output in the backline. It's a clear net loss for the team for me. You don't move a guy that is just about league best in his position.

[bornadog]

SA CLUB ENCOURAGED TO TARGET OFF-CONTRACT BULLDOG (https://www.sen.com.au/news/2021/04/22/sa-club-encouraged-to-target-off-contract-bulldog/)

Western Bulldogs speedster Ed Richards has been reportedly identified as a possible trade target for rival clubs.


The Herald Sun understands that Richards, who comes out of contract at the end of the season, could become a player of interest once he returns from an ankle injury.


The report also states that the Bulldogs want to keep the 21-year-old beyond this year.


Since debuting in 2018, Richards has played 58 games at Whitten Oval and has been used in a variety of positions.


Kane Cornes believes Adelaide would be an ideal fit for Richards if he were to explore his options at season’s end.


“Geez Adelaide could use him I reckon, in multiple positions,” he told SEN SA Breakfast.


“I’d be putting a call in 100 per cent if I was Adelaide.


“He fits their rebuild age demographically, plays multiple positions, has speed, he’s tough and he’s got a lot of talent. That’s where I’d be aiming.”


Richards injured his ankle in a VFL practice match in March and is still 4-6 weeks away from a return.


He appeared in 17 games for the Dogs in 2020.

[bulldogtragic]

Why didn’t Cornes just say “Richards for McAsey”. You know he wants to. Is that the next ‘scoop’?

[Testekill]

It honestly looked like this would be his year. Ideally we play him off the halfback flank and move JJ further up the ground.

[Axe Man]

It honestly looked like this would be his year. Ideally we play him off the halfback flank and move JJ further up the ground.

JJ isn't in our first choice back 7 at the moment. Assuming 2 KPDs (Keath & Gardner/Young) which 2 of the following players make way for Ed: Dale, Daniel, Duryea, Williams, Wood, Crozier? Very tough to squeeze Richards in there at the moment.

[Hotdog60]

Why didn’t Cornes just say “Richards for McAsey”. You know he wants to. Is that the next ‘scoop’?

Would that be a bad deal, I like Ed but another tallish defender would be good.

[Twodogs]

News flash from Kane Cornes



ED RICHARDS IS A DECENT PLAYER


In news today Kane Cornes breathlessly pointed out the bleeding obvious. For anyone who hasn't watched any football at all in the last 3 years he made the point that Western Bulldogs player Ed Richards goes alright. At least he didn't go with the tired old trope of linking him with Collingwood where he has family connections.

[jeemak]

I think I saw him at the butcher a couple of days ago, but it was at Vic Gardens in Richmond so not sure if it was him.........skinny lad if so.

[bulldogtragic]

Would that be a bad deal, I like Ed but another tallish defender would be good.

If we are interested in McAsey, I can see Adelaide probably wanting a player. Maybe it’s something to debate at a list management meeting especially if we want to use our first rounder.

[Mofra]

If we are interested in McAsey, I can see Adelaide probably wanting a player. Maybe it’s something to debate at a list management meeting especially if we want to use our first rounder.
McAsey is currently toiling away with unimpressive performances at SANFL level. Do we even want him?

[bulldogtragic]

McAsey is currently toiling away with unimpressive performances at SANFL level. Do we even want him?

I would, at a reasonable price.

[Go_Dogs]

So, Ed is not far away from returning.

After a promising start to his career, where his wheels were on show and his ball use looked sharp, he’s had a couple of years where he has stagnated to the point where he’s probably in the 18-30 range on our list.

What role do we see him playing when he comes back at VFL level and will he make a positive impact in the best 22 this year?

I’d still love to see him on a wing, but might be hard this year given our depth and his fitness levels. Half back we are stocked, albeit if Daniel spends more time up the field maybe there’s a spot. Our forward half could use his pace, but is he able to sacrifice his game and focus hard defensively to take one of those spots?

[soupman]

He played defence this hyear before getting injured I believe (small sample size I know and this was also before the emergency of Dale).

I would still be open to that. As to whether or not it's worth doing that when there aren't any spots available, we have shown of late a propensity to push Daniel into other spots around the ground (forward against Calrton, Mid against Freo) and Richards has also played those roles before, so we could see him basically share that role with Daniel, where we always have one in defence and the other wherever else we deem it necessary.

[1eyedog]

So, Ed is not far away from returning.

After a promising start to his career, where his wheels were on show and his ball use looked sharp, he’s had a couple of years where he has stagnated to the point where he’s probably in the 18-30 range on our list.

What role do we see him playing when he comes back at VFL level and will he make a positive impact in the best 22 this year?

I’d still love to see him on a wing, but might be hard this year given our depth and his fitness levels. Half back we are stocked, albeit if Daniel spends more time up the field maybe there’s a spot. Our forward half could use his pace, but is he able to sacrifice his game and focus hard defensively to take one of those spots?

I hope it's wing high half forward. Id like to maximum his speed and running capacity and feel he is a less than reliable kick coming out of defence.

[comrade]

I hope it's wing high half forward. Id like to maximum his speed and running capacity and feel he is a less than reliable kick coming out of defence.

Can you see him taking the role Roarke Smith is currently playing?

[1eyedog]

Can you see him taking the role Roarke Smith is currently playing?

It depends on the type of player we want in that position. If we need a defensive minded reliable player to play a more defensive role on a good opposition player we go with Roarke. If we're after more flow and a player who can cover more ground and help our connections maybe we consider Richards. This would likely change on a weekly basis.

What do you think? Can they both play in the same team? Who do you prefer or who else potentially comes out?

[jeemak]

I think the role Roarke plays could be up for grabs (even though he's been really solid), with Richards offering pace as a point of difference. The roles Scott and McNiel, and even JJ play are also opportunities for him.

Some better than decent form at VFL level will see him promoted because the MC thinks he's too good not to be playing.

[bornadog]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgCpW5-yK7o&ab_channel=Michael

[bornadog]

I enjoyed Ed taking them on, hopefully he keeps it up.


https://youtu.be/syEz4A7ph5c

[azabob]

Ed was my highlight from the weekend.

It was probably his most rounded game that I have seen him play.

His disposal efficiency was spot on, he took the game on with his run and carry - especially his pace and he also took some strong marks.

Hopefully this sets his season up.

[AshMac]

Ed was my highlight from the weekend.

It was probably his most rounded game that I have seen him play.

His disposal efficiency was spot on, he took the game on with his run and carry - especially his pace and he also took some strong marks.

Hopefully this sets his season up.

Agree. Big fan of his game against the bombers. Whose spot has he taken in the side? He’s definitely a defender and I can’t think off the top of my head who is out for him? Crozier?

[GVGjr]

Ed was my highlight from the weekend.

It was probably his most rounded game that I have seen him play.

His disposal efficiency was spot on, he took the game on with his run and carry - especially his pace and he also took some strong marks.

Hopefully this sets his season up.

He played well in his first season with us as a HBF and after a few years in other roles he has slotted back to his natural position and is performing better.

There was a lot to like about his game on Sunday.

[azabob]

Agree. Big fan of his game against the bombers. Whose spot has he taken in the side? He’s definitely a defender and I can’t think off the top of my head who is out for him? Crozier?

From memory Williams came in for Crozier.

It will be interesting to see who makes way for Keath when he is fit.

For mine it will have to be Williams or McComb/R.Smith/McNeil. Depending who may mean either Daniel, Williams or Richards is shuffled to a wing / midfield spot.

[Go_Dogs]

His work in the contest is a feature for mine. He’s rarely beaten, can halve contests vs multiple opponents, and is learning to balance his game appropriately with offence / defence.

If he can stay injury free, he’s a best 22 lock now.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Thought his start to the year was poor.

Had a good couple of weeks and looks to have stabilised. Good to see his contest game back and he's using the ball better.

[AshMac]

From memory Williams came in for Crozier.

It will be interesting to see who makes way for Keath when he is fit.

For mine it will have to be Williams or McComb/R.Smith/McNeil. Depending who may mean either Daniel, Williams or Richards is shuffled to a wing / midfield spot.

I cant see who he is in for as I thought O’Brien was in for Keath - though maybe it’s because Cordy seems to be playing as a swing.

Don’t like Richard’s on the wing, like him less on the forward line. I reckon he might be a one position player - back flank

[boydogs]

I cant see who he is in for as I thought O’Brien was in for Keath - though maybe it’s because Cordy seems to be playing as a swing.

Don’t like Richard’s on the wing, like him less on the forward line. I reckon he might be a one position player - back flank

Wood & Cordy have been replaced by O'Brien & Richards

[bornadog]

https://scontent.fmel16-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/283370616_10159773852567487_1071134104639187575_n.jpg?_nc_ca t=110&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=730e14&_nc_ohc=tI4QMbGYnN4AX-_CtyI&_nc_ht=scontent.fmel16-1.fna&oh=00_AT_gt2kzd1bwbqnKwEDiv8A5ym5lvBIm4zIozdegqxmXgw&oe=62912DC8

[Grantysghost]

https://scontent.fmel16-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/283370616_10159773852567487_1071134104639187575_n.jpg?_nc_ca t=110&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=730e14&_nc_ohc=tI4QMbGYnN4AX-_CtyI&_nc_ht=scontent.fmel16-1.fna&oh=00_AT_gt2kzd1bwbqnKwEDiv8A5ym5lvBIm4zIozdegqxmXgw&oe=62912DC8

Brian just kicked 8 goals for Caroline Springs. He's a forward BAD!

[Go_Dogs]

Good company on that list.

He’s always been a good congested player and solid in the air, I think his confidence and decision making has improved so now he’s able to cash in.

[GVGjr]

Good company on that list.

He’s always been a good congested player and solid in the air, I think his confidence and decision making has improved so now he’s able to cash in.

I'm rapt for him. He can be a very effective player for us and this is shaping as a real break out season for him.

[hujsh]

One day I'll learn why 50% of the pictures BAD post just don't appear for me unless I use a private browsing window (where the other 50% don't appear) and how I'm the only person affected by this issue.

Some theorize that the pure awe of his pictures are too much for my small, smooth brain to handle all at once.

[bornadog]

One day I'll learn why 50% of the pictures BAD post just don't appear for me unless I use a private browsing window (where the other 50% don't appear) and how I'm the only person affected by this issue.

Some theorize that the pure awe of his pictures are too much for my small, smooth brain to handle all at once.

What browser do you use?

[Grantysghost]

I'm rapt for him. He can be a very effective player for us and this is shaping as a real break out season for him.
He’s a ripper. I met him in his first season, he had struck up a friendship with the one and only Billy Gowers and Billy brought him over to me for an intro.

Lovely guy always smiling and very respectful. Got some great photos with those two boof heads that night !

So happy he’s getting a decent run at it.

[hujsh]

What browser do you use?

Just Firefox. Adblock unpaused and everything. That's how much I love this site.

[Grantysghost]

Just Firefox. Adblock unpaused and everything. That's how much I love this site.
Try clearing the cache.

https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/how-clear-firefox-cache

It’s going to do it for all sites though.

Alternatively just try chrome.

[hujsh]

Try clearing the cache.

https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/how-clear-firefox-cache

It’s going to do it for all sites though.

Alternatively just try chrome.


Both of these options sound terrible.

The first because I'm lazy and the second because it's Chrome. I choose to continue to suffer (also thanks)

edit: as a side note it's very strange that the Geelong club website has 14mb of cookies and trackers on me from the 1-2 times I've been there to look at players I'd like us to take. The most of any webiste by a decent amount. I may not have fixed my issue but I may have learned GFC is spying on me specifically

[Grantysghost]

Both of these options sound terrible.

The first because I'm lazy and the second because it's Chrome. I choose to continue to suffer (also thanks)

edit: as a side note it's very strange that the Geelong club website has 14mb of cookies and trackers on me from the 1-2 times I've been there to look at players I'd like us to take. The most of any webiste by a decent amount. I may not have fixed my issue but I may have learned GFC is spying on me specifically
That is interesting! Bloody Geelong :)

[FrediKanoute]

Good company on that list.

He’s always been a good congested player and solid in the air, I think his confidence and decision making has improved so now he’s able to cash in.

Is it any wonder that he's doing well now that he is being played in the right role?

[Testekill]

Richards is equal second for contested marks in our team with 11, Bontempelli is also on 11. Naughton is obviously a mile out in front.

[GVGjr]

Richards on RSN

"I struggled to be that player that was constantly moving around. I wanted to settle down at half-back."

@westernbulldogs
young star Ed Richards says he asked to be settled after stints on a wing and half-forward. Now in career best form in his natural slot.

[azabob]

Richards on RSN

"I struggled to be that player that was constantly moving around. I wanted to settle down at half-back."

@westernbulldogs
young star Ed Richards says he asked to be settled after stints on a wing and half-forward. Now in career best form in his natural slot.

He has had a ripping year. Maybe a top 5 B&F finish on the cards?

[GVGjr]

He has had a ripping year. Maybe a top 5 B&F finish on the cards?

He's been a very consistent performer and has added something to the back line. For me, probably closer to top 10 but you never know.

[azabob]

Richards on RSN

"I struggled to be that player that was constantly moving around. I wanted to settle down at half-back."

@westernbulldogs
young star Ed Richards says he asked to be settled after stints on a wing and half-forward. Now in career best form in his natural slot.

Here is the interview.

https://player.whooshkaa.com/episode?id=1031092

[Grantysghost]

Richards on RSN

"I struggled to be that player that was constantly moving around. I wanted to settle down at half-back."

@westernbulldogs
young star Ed Richards says he asked to be settled after stints on a wing and half-forward. Now in career best form in his natural slot.

Fair play to the coaches, they are often pilloried for their play anywhere methodology but here they've listened to the player and it's worked a treat.
He is really fulfilling the potential we all knew he had. I've loved Ed since his first season when he was tagging around with Billy Gowers at a player sponsors function. I think Bill was teaching him the ropes so he was bringing over to people and introducing him. He was so nervous but with Billy the clown there it was ok :) He is a good guy Gowers.

[anfo27]

At the end of last year I thought Ed has been a disappointment, wasn't a best 22 player & why did the club hold this kid in such a high regard. Been the most pleasing surprise to see Ed play so well off half back. Gives us something that Daniel & Dale can't bring in daring run. Better in the air than both & i think a better defender as well.
Also feel that him playing so well back there & having Dale back kind of leaves Daniel out of position down there. Daniel needs a reinvention me thinks.

[GVGjr]

At the end of last year I thought Ed has been a disappointment, wasn't a best 22 player & why did the club hold this kid in such a high regard. Been the most pleasing surprise to see Ed play so well off half back. Gives us something that Daniel & Dale can't bring in daring run. Better in the air than both & i think a better defender as well.
Also feel that him playing so well back there & having Dale back kind of leaves Daniel out of position down there. Daniel needs a reinvention me thinks.

We could certainly use Daniel in other areas and next year might be the time to reinvent him into a forward or mid.

[Mofra]

We could certainly use Daniel in other areas and next year might be the time to reinvent him into a forward or mid.
Daniel is a brilliant inside 50 kick, especially if it's a slow entry. He's our bench utility who can play anywhere

[anfo27]

We could certainly use Daniel in other areas and next year might be the time to reinvent him into a forward or mid.

I would like to see that. He has the skill set to be a goal assist king Caleb. I've even liked seeing Treloar down there of late. He takes the game on more with run.

[boydogs]

I've even liked seeing Treloar down there of late. He takes the game on more with run.

Gives away an uncontested mark 20m out from goal every week. We're playing too many rebounders that can't defend. I would send JJ back

[Mantis]

Gives away an uncontested mark 20m out from goal every week. We're playing too many rebounders that can't defend. I would send JJ back

Why do you think JJ was shifted from defence?

[hujsh]

Why do you think JJ was shifted from defence?

Maybe I'm misremembering but I recall it being that he was easily tagged out of the game in defence. I don't remember him struggling to defend necessarily.

[boydogs]

Why do you think JJ was shifted from defence?

Was it that he couldn’t break a tag, so he became the tagger? Even if he’s tagged again, he can defend better than Daniel & Treloar and Dale & Richards can rebound untagged

[jeemak]

He was moved forward because we needed pace in that part of the ground and had more creative users behind the ball squeezing him out.

The whole couldn't break a tag thing was overplayed, and not reflected in his Sutton Medal standings when he was still being highly rated by the MC whilst playing defencive half roles.

[GVGjr]

He was moved forward because we needed pace in that part of the ground and had more creative users behind the ball squeezing him out.

The whole couldn't break a tag thing was overplayed, and not reflected in his Sutton Medal standings when he was still being highly rated by the MC whilst playing defencive half roles.

JJ's actually done pretty well as a forward and we should remember that he received a couple of dirty tags where his team mates should have done more to help him.

Did we move him forward after we tried Wood there?

[azabob]

He was moved forward because we needed pace in that part of the ground and had more creative users behind the ball squeezing him out.

The whole couldn't break a tag thing was overplayed, and not reflected in his Sutton Medal standings when he was still being highly rated by the MC whilst playing defencive half roles.

I must admit I am quite surprised by this. Finished top 10 in 2017/18/19.

[jeemak]

I must admit I am quite surprised by this. Finished top 10 in 2017/18/19.

I've only posted it 500 times.

But I have a few hobby horses so I can see why I'd be ignored!

[Grantysghost]

I've only posted it 500 times.

But I have a few hobby horses so I can see why I'd be ignored!

Suckling came 7th one year. I want to hear from EW about the integrity of the top 10 places.

[EasternWest]

Suckling came 7th one year. I want to hear from EW about the integrity of the top 10 places.

How bad were we going?

Although that's part of my frustration with Suckling. He could play, just most of the time he chose not to.

[Grantysghost]

How bad were we going?

Although that's part of my frustration with Suckling. He could play, just most of the time he chose not to.

2017, he was the only one sober.

[EasternWest]

2017, he was the only one sober.

Oh that's right because he didn't get to play in our premiership because he was "injured".

[Happy Days]

Oh that's right because he didn't get to play in our premiership because he was "injured".

Can you imagine the alternate timeline where we drop Biggs for Suckling? Thought it was certain to happen at the time.

I don’t even mind Suckling but that would’ve thrown the universe out of order and we would’ve lost by a million.

[Scorlibo]

Can you imagine the alternate timeline where we drop Biggs for Suckling? Thought it was certain to happen at the time.

I don’t even mind Suckling but that would’ve thrown the universe out of order and we would’ve lost by a million.

There wouldn't have that special something to #neverforget

[EasternWest]

Can you imagine the alternate timeline where we drop Biggs for Suckling? Thought it was certain to happen at the time.

I don’t even mind Suckling but that would’ve thrown the universe out of order and we would’ve lost by a million.

Thoughts like this keep me awake at night.


There wouldn't have that special something to #neverforget

I dunno. You might have read the headline "AFL player zotted in the head by beer cup thrown from second level".

[Axe Man]

Thoughts like this keep me awake at night.



I dunno. You might have read the headline "AFL player zotted in the head by beer cup thrown from second level".

Well la-de-da someone sits on the second level. Shouldn't you be drinking Grange up there?

[EasternWest]

Well la-de-da someone sits on the second level. Shouldn't you be drinking Grange up there?

I have two hands.

[Mofra]

Suckling came 7th one year. I want to hear from EW about the integrity of the top 10 places.
Lukas Markovic came 10th one year

[Happy Days]

Lukas Markovic came 10th one year

And Brendan McCartney hand to god tried to claim some credit for 2016. Embarrassing.

[EasternWest]

And Brendan McCartney hand to god tried to claim some credit for 2016. Embarrassing.

Doesn't he though?

His insistence on players with a hard edge and "cracking in" meant we had some legitimate tough guys in 2016. It's something we're definitely lacking now.

[bornadog]

Congratulations to Ed for 100 games coming up this week.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RckUIkpgHG8

[hujsh]

Did we get him as part of the Stringer Trade? Looking at him tonight I'd consider us a the winners if it was a straight trade Stringer for Richards

[bulldogtragic]

Did we get him as part of the Stringer Trade? Looking at him tonight I'd consider us a the winners if it was a straight trade Stringer for Richards

Part of it with our other picks added. Schache included too. But we gave up picks used on gun players too.

[anfo27]

Doesn't get talked about enough Ed. He is a tough hombre Ed with some nice wheels, gun! Would like to see us utilise his speed out of defence more. He could really be an offensive weapon for us back there.

[Mofra]

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/07/23/the-10-best-and-worst-kicks-inside-50-in-the-afl-in-2024-according-to/


1. Ed Richards (Western Bulldogs)

Hoyne: “Ed Richards is the best kick inside 50 and there’s a significant gap between the top two and everyone else.”

If Baz wants a big big money deal - give the cash to Ed instead?

[The Underdog]

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/07/23/the-10-best-and-worst-kicks-inside-50-in-the-afl-in-2024-according-to/



If Baz wants a big big money deal - give the cash to Ed instead?

Admittedly, I’ve been Ed-pilled from early days but this is the correct take.

[mjp]

Doesn't get talked about enough Ed. He is a tough hombre Ed with some nice wheels, gun! Would like to see us utilise his speed out of defence more. He could really be an offensive weapon for us back there.

In our house, we all call him "Ed" we he is doing great things (most of the time) and "Ted" when he is battling...

Does anyone else do this??

[Happy Days]

When he’s going bad I mostly hit him with this:


https://youtu.be/rjPEkh-1S4E?si=dL8gGFaGlPdgLtU6

[D Mitchell]

In our house, we all call him "Ed" we he is doing great things (most of the time) and "Ted" when he is battling...

Does anyone else do this??

Good or bad, he's Richards. It's only for the very special that a nickname, shortened name or firstname is bestowed. Bont is the sole current bestowed.

[Go_Dogs]

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/07/23/the-10-best-and-worst-kicks-inside-50-in-the-afl-in-2024-according-to/



If Baz wants a big big money deal - give the cash to Ed instead?

Really interesting list. A few players the media fawn over in the “bad entries” category. Love a bit of data telling us experts have got it wrong.

[Mofra]

Really interesting list. A few players the media fawn over in the “bad entries” category. Love a bit of data telling us experts have got it wrong.
I think CD often have to be taken with a grain of salt, given Houston is at no 2 and he probably has far fewer entries than other blokes in that top 10.
It does show Ed's value to us though as his numbers since moving into the midfield are outstanding. Almost 5 tackles per game certainly helps us too