PDA

View Full Version : Cooney vs Judd 2008


Throughandthrough
19-06-2008, 03:08 PM
Cooney


12 games 308 disposals 18 goals 31 tackles 3 HO


Judd


12 games 294 disposals 9 goals 40 tackles 0 ho
LostDoggy
19-06-2008, 03:11 PM
Jeez, Judd is having a better season then I thought. Judd's 3rd for clearances(Cooney 10th) and 2nd for most for contested possessions (Cooney not in the top 45)
craigsahibee
19-06-2008, 04:11 PM
Jeez, Judd is having a better season then I thought. Judd's 3rd for clearances(Cooney 10th) and 2nd for most for contested possessions (Cooney not in the top 45)

Yes, but who else in the league can rack up those possession numbers and also get 3 Hit-Outs. Cooney is the complete package.
Throughandthrough
19-06-2008, 04:23 PM
Where is Cooney in handball's received?


Top 5 i presume?
Mofra
19-06-2008, 04:39 PM
1 of those hitouts was a boundary throw in last week when he was the genuine ruckman (not a 3rd man up). As was his centre HO vs Cox.

Judd isn't as potent if/when resting the forward line however his in-close ability is phenominal
Scorlibo
19-06-2008, 06:00 PM
Cooney not in the top 45 in contested possessions?? Thats very surprising. Cooney is a much better player than Judd this year, but if Judd were with us as opposed to Carlton then they would probably be level.
LostDoggy
19-06-2008, 06:36 PM
Wow..i read a thing in the paper about Judd playing as good as 2006..

Dont think he's gunna be in Brownlow top 5 or anythin though..
Bumper Bulldogs
19-06-2008, 08:47 PM
Wow..i read a thing in the paper about Judd playing as good as 2006..

Dont think he's gunna be in Brownlow top 5 or anythin though..

Don't think he will play as long as coons ether
Mantis
19-06-2008, 10:07 PM
Jeez, Judd is having a better season then I thought. Judd's 3rd for clearances(Cooney 10th) and 2nd for most for contested possessions (Cooney not in the top 45)

Didn't believe this so I just had a look on the afl website:

Contested Possessions (Top 10):

Chris Judd - 138
Gary Ablett (jnr) - 124
Simon Black - 122
Luke Ball - 119
Nathan Foley - 115
Adam Cooney - 112
Luke Power - 110
Shane O'Bree - 106
Aaron Sandilands - 104
Daniel Cross - 104

Now I know the afl website a big pile of poo, but they couldn't have it this wrong??
LostDoggy
19-06-2008, 11:39 PM
Didn't believe this so I just had a look on the afl website:

Contested Possessions (Top 10):

Chris Judd - 138
Gary Ablett (jnr) - 124
Simon Black - 122
Luke Ball - 119
Nathan Foley - 115
Adam Cooney - 112
Luke Power - 110
Shane O'Bree - 106
Aaron Sandilands - 104
Daniel Cross - 104

Now I know the afl website a big pile of poo, but they couldn't have it this wrong??

I got my stats here.



http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/player_rankings?yr=2008&sp=SE&rt=LT&fc=E6 (http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/player_rankings?yr=2008&sp=SE&rt=LT&fc=E6)

There's a big difference between the two sites. They must have differing opinions on what a contested ball is.

Judd = 68 Contested possies = 2nd place
Cooney = 30 = and is outside the top 45