Woof Player Awards Rnd 16 - Western Bulldogs vs Geelong

[BulldogBelle]

There are two awards that you can vote on, once the game is completed.

Voting closes each Tuesday at 8.00 pm


The first one is for the Joe Marmo Medal for the best players on the ground.

There are 4 votes allocated and it's a 4 for the best and of course 3, 2 and 1.

and

The second award is for the Ron James Medal for the best 2 pups on the ground.

2 Votes allocated - 2 being for the best pup and 1 for the runner-up
Remember the cut off age for a pup is 22 as at the 1st of January, 2008

Pups Eligible for James -

Addison, Boumann, Everitt, Grant, Griffen, Harbrow, Higgins, Hill, Lynch, O'Keefe, O'Shea, Ray, Reid, Stack, Tiller, Ward, Williams,Wood

[1eyedog]

Well I'll start it off then, pretty poor performance today accentuated by some terrible umpiring. I gave my votes to those who went in to get the ball.

4- Addison (good on him for having a go as nobody else did)
3- Eagleton (If Eagle gets 3 votes in the team we have something is seriously wrong)
2- Ray (thought his endeavour was good but his disposal let him down again)
1- Gilbee (was ok in patches and spotted up targets well)

[Rocket Science]

4 - Hudson
3 - Gilbee
2 - Addison
1 - Cross

Much easier finding blokes who went missing this week than those who pulled their weight.

[Scorlibo]

4 - Gilbee, Our best by a mile IMO the only one willing to consistently endeavour through Geelong's defense and do it with precision and intelligence.

3 - Addison, Tackled hard and was first to the ball and just proved what a good young contested ball winner he is.

2 - Cross, Another who went in first, won the frees for his efforts and although he seemed jittery with his possessions, rarely venturing outside the handball to a player beside him, his pressure around the stoppages and ball winning were still important.

1 - Ray, Thought he used the ball well and handled the pressure from Geelong very well.

Gia would have featured if he hadn't dropped a few marks he should have taken inside the forward fifty.

2 - Addison
1 - Ray

[The Coon Dog]

4. Lindsay Gilbee
3. Daniel Cross
2. Farren Ray
1. Daniel Giansiracusa

[wimberga]

4-Gilbee
3-Hargrave
2-Addison
1-Eagleton

2-Ray
1-Addison

[Mantis]

I thought Addison was bloody horrible. His endeavour was good as it always is, but his ability to read the ball and follow his man was well below an acceptable level.

4. Gilbee
3. Cooney
2. Hargrave
1. .........

[Scorlibo]

4-Gilbee
3-Hargrave
2-Addison
1-Eagleton
Ray

2-Ray
1-Addison

Huh?

[wimberga]

Huh?

I thought Addison was one of our better players today and did alright in what was not his normal role.

I put Ray ahead of Addison in the votes for the best Young player as his run and carry was pretty decent in teh first half.

I thought they both deserved votes, thats how i saw it so thats how i allocated them

[Mantis]

I thought Addison was one of our better players today and did alright in what was not his normal role.

I put Ray ahead of Addison in the votes for the best Young player as his run and carry was pretty decent in teh first half.

I thought they both deserved votes, thats how i saw it so thats how i allocated them

The point being made was that you gave Addison votes in the Marmo, but didn't give votes to Ray. Yet in the James voting you gave Ray 2 and Addison 1.

Doesn't make sense...

[Scorlibo]

I thought Addison was one of our better players today and did alright in what was not his normal role.

I put Ray ahead of Addison in the votes for the best Young player as his run and carry was pretty decent in teh first half.

I thought they both deserved votes, thats how i saw it so thats how i allocated them

OK, sorry I thought you had just had a brain fade.

[wimberga]

Yeah your right Mantis, That was the point he was making.

The point I was making was that I felt that they both deserved to get votes. I put Addison in the bests because i thought he tried his heart out and had a good affect on the game. I gave Ray votes in the young players because i thought of all the young players, he played the best, it was just that Addison had more affect IMO

[BulldogBelle]

4. Gilbee
3. Hargrave
2. Addison
1. Ray

2.Addison
1. Ray

[Mofra]

4. Hargrave
3. Hudson
2. Boyd
1. Ray

2. Tiller (mostly for his spoil on Mooney & efforts at forcing stoppages in the backline)
1. Ray

[bold-dogg]

4. Hudson
3. Addison
2. Giansiracusa
1. Tiller

2. Addison
1. Tiller

[GVGjr]

Marmo
4 - Hargrave
3 - Gilbee
2 - Cross
1 - Addison

Giansiracusa a bit unlucky not to get a vote

James
2 - Addison
1 - Ray

[BulldogBelle]

4 Gilbee
3 Hargy
2 Griffen
1 Cross

2 Griffen..no love for him this week?
1 Addison

[BulldogBelle]

Marmo

4. Lindsay Gilbee
3. Ryan Hargrave
2. Daniel Cross
1. Daniel Giansiracusa

James

2. Farren Ray
1. Ryan Griffen

[Mantis]

4 Gilbee
3 Hargy
2 Griffen
1 Cross

2 Griffen..no love for him this week?
1 Addison

Our players are the one's with the red on there jumpers....

[The Coon Dog]

Our players are the one's with the red on there jumpers....

Griff did turn it over today, didn't he?

[hujsh]

Gia
Hudson
Gilbee
Cross

[Mantis]

Griff did turn it over today, didn't he?

On MMM they mentioned he had 14 kicks for the game, 9 were marked by Geelong player's.

Not sure if this was due to his poor kicking or poor work up the field, possibly a bit of both.

[Sedat]

Marmo:
4 - Gia
3 - Cooney
2 - Addison
1 - Ray

James:
2 - Addison
1 - Ray

[Scraggers]

Marmo

4) - Ben Hudson
3) - Lindsay Gilbee
2) - Adam Cooney
1) - Daniel G-Spot

James

2) - Farren Ray
1) - Dylan Addison

[becmatty]

4. Giansiracusa
3. Gibee
2. Eagleton
1. Griffen

Pups:
2. Griffen
1. Ray

[Sockeye Salmon]

4 Gilbee
3 Gia
2 Hargrave
1 Cooney


Hard to give them this week.

[bornadog]

4. Gilbee
3. Hargrave
2. Cross
1. Eagelton

Ray
Addison

[mjp]

Marmo
4. Gilbee
3. Gia
2. Hudson
1. Shaggy

James
2. Ray
1. Addison (for effort, not for smarts)

[LostDoggy]

4 - Gilbee
3 - Cross
2 - Gia
1 - Cooney

[LostDoggy]

4 - Hargrave - I have reserved judgement on Shaggy for many a year, but yesterday he just showed his class over the four quarters. Clean hands off the ground, one grab mark, defended well enough for his part, found space to receive, clean disposal off the backline. Shone yesterday in the murk.
3 - Gilbee - Some incredible clearing kicks to advantage, ran all day, spoilt well as third man up etc.
2 - Johnno - Ok, I know it's an unfashionable vote, but in the first three quarters he did some very good things. Let himself down with some easy misses, but at one stage when the game was there to be won he went and put himself in the middle and won the clearance. Inspirational, captain-type stuff. He's definitely not 100% though is he.
1 - Coons - got a bit of the ball. Is it just me or is he not thinking through his disposal? He has incredible kicking skills but he's missing the mark a lot or just dropping it short. Something's NQR.

2 - Addison
1 - Harbrow

[Go_Dogs]

4. Gilbee
3. Cooney
2. Hargrave
1. Eagleton

[LostDoggy]

4 Gilbee
3 Addison
2 Gia
1 Hargrave

2 Addison
1 Ray

[Happy Days]

4. Gilbee
3. Cooney
2. Eagleton
1. Hudson

2. Ray
1. Addison

[1eyedog]

4 Hudson
3 Cross
2 Cooney
1 Griffen

2 Griffen
1 Ray


:eek: He was awful!

[Crizza]

4 Gia
3 Gilbee
2 Ray
1 Hargrave

2 Addison
1 Tiller
_________

[LostDoggy]

4. Shaggy 3. Gilbs 2. Ray 1. Tiller .......2. Ray 1. Tiller

[Ozza]

4. Gilbee - easily our best.
3. Gia - Very good with the ball as usual.
2. Hudson - Worked hard - unfortunately not getting great support from Will the last few weeks.
1. Cooney - Not many others to choose from - he still got plenty of it.

RJ:
2. Addison
1. Ray

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Marmo

4. Gilbee
3. Guido
2. Shaggy
1. Cross

James

2 Ray
1. Addison

[BulldogBelle]

Voting is now closed.