BulldogBelle
16-05-2009, 01:33 AM
Eade to be put through a list of measurements/KPI's....
Western Bulldogs run tough new rule over Eade (http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,25489883-2722,00.html)
The Australian
Stephen Rielly | May 16, 2009
THE Western Bulldogs are going to pass the final season of coach Rodney Eade's contract through a series of filters -- as many as five -- before offering him a new deal.
It is understood that while the Dogs are leaning towards the idea of a two-year extension for Eade, before that offer is made his current campaign will be evaluated according to a list of measurements, or key performance indicators, framed to look deeper than results alone.
The list is believed to include such things as organisational ability, game-plan versatility and how Eade can be expected to adapt to future changes within the club and the game.
In an attempt to measure him by more than mere ladder position, the number that football clubs have worshipped for all time -- the win-loss ratio -- will sit outside of the evaluation.
Not that winning and losing will be dismissed entirely, but the Bulldogs are understood to be working to a theory that it is possible for a coach to take a team into the top six and not do a particularly good job in getting there.
Equally, by turning to a list of set measurables, it is possible for a coach to finish outside the top eight but rate well.
"What's being asked is the question: 'How do we measure a coach?"' an insider said yesterday.
Much of the impetus for the establishment of the measurement process is coming from director George Pappas, a senior adviser with the Boston Consulting Group.
Pappas is one of the five-member football sub-committee that will ultimately make a recommendation on Eade, who led the Bulldogs to a preliminary final last year and has coached the club since 2005. It is understood that Eade is after a three-year contract.
President David Smorgon, chief executive Campbell Rose, football operations manager James Fantasia and football director Simon Garlick are the other members of the sub-committee.
It was with Pappas' urging that the Dogs hired a management consultancy firm to conduct a review of the football department in 2007, which led to Fantasia's appointment, an organisational restructure and Eade being divested of some of his non-coaching responsibilities.
Fantasia declined to comment yesterday other than to say the process is collaborative and will be applied across the football department, that Eade will not be the only member of the department to have his performance filtered, or sifted, through the measurements.
"All I can say is that we're working with Rodney on this. We're not sitting up above him, in judgment. He's involved and he's been kept informed of what we're measuring and how we're going to do it," he said.
Eade is one of seven coaches due to fall out of contract at the end of the season, with change certain at Richmond and conceivable at Collingwood, North Melbourne, Port Adelaide and West Coast. Mark Thompson at Geelong is as safe as any coach could be and is expected to receive an offer of a two-year extension in the coming months.
Eade has said a number of times this season that he wants to remain at Whitten Oval, where he has built a 54-44-2 record that includes a sixth-place finish in 2006 and a finish of third last year. The team that plays Melbourne today is third on the ladder with a 4-3 record.
The Dogs have indicated, too, that they are more likely to offer Eade a new deal than not, but it seems the terms of the contract may now reflect the outcome of the assessment.
Western Bulldogs run tough new rule over Eade (http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,25489883-2722,00.html)
The Australian
Stephen Rielly | May 16, 2009
THE Western Bulldogs are going to pass the final season of coach Rodney Eade's contract through a series of filters -- as many as five -- before offering him a new deal.
It is understood that while the Dogs are leaning towards the idea of a two-year extension for Eade, before that offer is made his current campaign will be evaluated according to a list of measurements, or key performance indicators, framed to look deeper than results alone.
The list is believed to include such things as organisational ability, game-plan versatility and how Eade can be expected to adapt to future changes within the club and the game.
In an attempt to measure him by more than mere ladder position, the number that football clubs have worshipped for all time -- the win-loss ratio -- will sit outside of the evaluation.
Not that winning and losing will be dismissed entirely, but the Bulldogs are understood to be working to a theory that it is possible for a coach to take a team into the top six and not do a particularly good job in getting there.
Equally, by turning to a list of set measurables, it is possible for a coach to finish outside the top eight but rate well.
"What's being asked is the question: 'How do we measure a coach?"' an insider said yesterday.
Much of the impetus for the establishment of the measurement process is coming from director George Pappas, a senior adviser with the Boston Consulting Group.
Pappas is one of the five-member football sub-committee that will ultimately make a recommendation on Eade, who led the Bulldogs to a preliminary final last year and has coached the club since 2005. It is understood that Eade is after a three-year contract.
President David Smorgon, chief executive Campbell Rose, football operations manager James Fantasia and football director Simon Garlick are the other members of the sub-committee.
It was with Pappas' urging that the Dogs hired a management consultancy firm to conduct a review of the football department in 2007, which led to Fantasia's appointment, an organisational restructure and Eade being divested of some of his non-coaching responsibilities.
Fantasia declined to comment yesterday other than to say the process is collaborative and will be applied across the football department, that Eade will not be the only member of the department to have his performance filtered, or sifted, through the measurements.
"All I can say is that we're working with Rodney on this. We're not sitting up above him, in judgment. He's involved and he's been kept informed of what we're measuring and how we're going to do it," he said.
Eade is one of seven coaches due to fall out of contract at the end of the season, with change certain at Richmond and conceivable at Collingwood, North Melbourne, Port Adelaide and West Coast. Mark Thompson at Geelong is as safe as any coach could be and is expected to receive an offer of a two-year extension in the coming months.
Eade has said a number of times this season that he wants to remain at Whitten Oval, where he has built a 54-44-2 record that includes a sixth-place finish in 2006 and a finish of third last year. The team that plays Melbourne today is third on the ladder with a 4-3 record.
The Dogs have indicated, too, that they are more likely to offer Eade a new deal than not, but it seems the terms of the contract may now reflect the outcome of the assessment.