2011 Best & Fairest - All Clubs

[The Coon Dog]

As each club conducts their Best & Fairest counts, I'll update the list as I usually do.

Adelaide:
83 Scott Thompson
50 Nathan van Berlo
38 Ben Rutten
38 Graham Johncock
35 Patrick Dangerfield
34 Rory Sloane
33 Bernie Vince
31 Sam Jacobs
28 Brent Reilly
25 Kurt Tippett

Brisbane:
37.5 Tom Rockliff
35.5 Simon Black
35 Jack Redden
32.5 Jed Adcock
32.5 Pearce Hanley
31.5 Matthew Leuenberger
25 Ash McGrath
22 Todd Banfield
20.5 Daniel Merrett
20.5 Joel Patfull

Carlton:
678 Marc Murphy
469 Chris Judd
448 Bryce Gibbs
408 Heath Scotland
376 Kade Simpson
319 Andrew Walker
301 Mitch Robinson
285 Eddie Betts
257 Michael Jamison
237 Chris Yarran

Collingwood:
65 Scott Pendlebury
54 Dane Swan
53 Travis Cloke
49 Luke Ball
47 Leon Davis
46 Dale Thomas
44 Ben Reid
43 Harry O'Brien
41 Jarryd Blair
40 Chris Tarrant

Essendon:
332 David Zaharakis
313 Brett Stanton
292 Michael Hurley
270 Jobe Watson
248 Heath Hocking
231 Dustin Fletcher
226 Dyson Heppell
225 Stewart Crameri
224 Paddy Ryder
216 Ben Howlett

Fremantle:
144 Matthew Pavlich
141 Nathan Fyfe
118 Greg Broughton
103 Luke McPharlin
102 David Mundy
98 Aaron Sandilands
94 Stephen Hill
88 Antoni Grover
83 Hayden Ballantyne
72 Chris Mayne

Geelong:
150 Corey Enright
143 Joel Corey
142 Jimmy Bartel
138 Cameron Ling
138 James Kelly
137 Joel Selwood
137 Matthew Scarlett
137 Steve Johnson
136 James Podsiadly
134 Harry Taylor

Gold Coast:
196 Gary Ablett
138 Nathan Bock
100 Michael Rischitelli
98 David Swallow
95 Danny Stanley
93 Zac Smith
83 Jared Brennan
82 Jarrod Harbrow
49 Sam Iles
45 Harley Bennell & Trent McKenzie

Hawthorn:
177 Sam Mitchell
160 Josh Gibson
138 Grant Birchall
135 Lance Franklin
126 Luke Hodge
125 Jordan Lewis
105 Liam Shiels
103 Cyril Rioli
102 Brad Sewell
86 Shaun Burgoyne

Melbourne:
227 Brent Moloney
201 Jared Rivers
178 James Frawley
171 Nathan Jones
170 Jack Trengove
156 Colin Garland
154 Mark Jamar
147 Stefan Martin
145 Jack Watts
143 Colin Sylvia

North Melbourne:
46 Daniel Wells
46 Andrew Swallow
36 Drew Petrie
36 Brent Harvey
35 Leigh Adams
30 Jack Ziebell
28 Todd Goldstein
26 Brady Rawlings
26 Aaron Edwards
25 Scott Thompson


Port Adelaide:
13 Travis Boak
13 Jackson Trengove
10 Tom Logan
9 Robbie Gray
8 Danyle Pearce
8 Justin Westhoff
7 Alipate Carlile
7 Troy Chaplin
7 Hamish Hartlett
7 Jasper Pittard
7 David Rodan
7 Jay Schulz

Richmond:
236 Trent Cotchin
203 Brett Deledio
198 Dustin Martin
181 Bachar Houli
181 Ty Vickory
159 Alex Rance
159 Robin Nahas
150 Nathan Foley
149 Jack Riewoldt
137 Shaun Grigg

St.Kilda:
557 Sam Fisher
554 Nick Dal Santo
490 Sean Dempster
487 Leigh Montagna
418 Stephen Milne
401 Clint Jones
392 Adam Schneider
384 Nick Reiwoldt
376 Brendon Goddard
371 Jason Gram

Sydney:
615 Adam Goodes
573 Rhyce Shaw
573 Josh Kennedy
542 Ryan O’Keefe
523 Ted Richards
519 Nick Smith
488 Daniel Hannebery
439 Shane Mumford
411 Ben McGlynn
396 Jarrad McVeigh

West Coast:
398 Darren Glass
398 Matt Priddis
397 Dean Cox
374 Shannon Hurn
359 Luke Shuey
342 Adam Selwood
338 Nic Naitanui
333 Andrew Embley
333 Mark Nicoski
332 Scott Selwood

Western Bulldogs:
140 Matthew Boyd
130 Robert Murphy
99 Ryan Griffen
84 Callan Ward
81 Dale Morris
74 Daniel Cross
72 Daniel Giansiracusa
66 Lian Picken
51 Barry Hall
42 Lukas Markovic
42 Shaun Higgins

[Ozza]

Although its been a horrible year, I'm looking forward to going along to B&F night.
Anyone else going?

I'm really hoping Bob Murphy can win the Charlie Sutton Medal - I think it would be befitting of his career to be known as a 'Club Best and Fairest winner' and he has had an exceptional season in a backline thats been more under the pump and undermanned than in previous years.

[SlimPickens]

Although its been a horrible year, I'm looking forward to going along to B&F night.
Anyone else going?

I'm really hoping Bob Murphy can win the Charlie Sutton Medal - I think it would be befitting of his career to be known as a 'Club Best and Fairest winner' and he has had an exceptional season in a backline thats been more under the pump and undermanned than in previous years.

Agree Ozza, Bobs year has been outstanding. His leadership in defence should bode well when the votes are handed out.

[The Coon Dog]

Who will win it at each club? My guesses are:

Scott Thompson
Matthew Leuenberger
Chris Judd
Dane Swan
Jobe Watson
Nathan Fyffe
James Kelly
Gary Ablett
Sam Mitchell
Brent Moloney
David Swallow
Robbie Gray
Brett Deledio
Nick Dal Santo
Adam Goodes
Dean Cox
Matthew Boyd

[Ozza]

Scott Thompson
Tom Rockliff
Chris Judd
Scott Pendlebury
Dyson Heppell
Nathan Fyfe
James Kelly
Gary Ablett
Sam Mitchell
Brent moloney
David Swallow
Port - I have no idea...Cassisi is pretty solid most weeks
Trent Cotchin
Nick Dal Santo
Adam Goodes
Dean Cox
Bob Murphy

[boydogs]

Always enjoy this thread TCD, thanks for putting in the effort. Tipping Boyd for the Dogs.

[bornadog]

Always enjoy this thread TCD, thanks for putting in the effort. Tipping Boyd for the Dogs.

Yeah he will probably get it but I would love to see Bob Murphy being rewarded, he has had a great season, thanks to no major injuries.

[Greystache]

Yeah he will probably get it but I would love to see Bob Murphy being rewarded, he has had a great season, thanks to no major injuries.

He's had a few quiet games towards the end of the season but I think Griffen will still be in the lead.

[The Coon Dog]

Scott Thompson a runaway winner of the Malcolm Blight Medal at Adelaide.

The top 10 are:

83 Scott Thompson
50 Nathan van Berlo
38 Ben Rutten
38 Graham Johncock
35 Patrick Dangerfield
34 Rory Sloane
33 Bernie Vince
31 Sam Jacobs
28 Brent Reilly
25 Kurt Tippett

As each club's vote count is completed I'll update this thread & have all clubs details in the initial post.

[The Coon Dog]

Again, another run away winner with Gary Ablett taking out the inaugural Best & Fairest at the Gold Coast.

The top 10are:

196 Gary Ablett
138 Nathan Bock
100 Michael Rischitelli
98 David Swallow
95 Danny Stanley
93 Zac Smith
83 Jared Brennan
82 Jarrod Harbrow
49 Sam Iles
45 Harley Bennell & Trent McKenzie

[The Bulldogs Bite]

If Stanley finishes fifth in your B&F, you know you have a long way to go.

Really hope Murphy wins ours. By far our most influential player.

[azabob]

Again, another run away winner with Gary Ablett taking out the inaugural Best & Fairest at the Gold Coast.

The top 10are:

196 Gary Ablett
138 Nathan Bock
100 Michael Rischitelli
98 David Swallow
95 Danny Stanley
93 Zac Smith
83 Jared Brennan
82 Jarrod Harbrow
49 Sam Iles
45 Harley Bennell & Trent McKenzie

Hmmm wonder where Gary would prefer to be? At the MCG winning the first final or accepting a B&F on the Gold Coast?

Would GC be disappointed with Harbrows output?

[Topdog]

Of course they would be he was very disappointing this year.

[Maddog37]

Danny Stanley has done a good job this year.

[ledge]

Tommy Rocliffe beat Simon Black to win Brisbanes B and F.

[The Coon Dog]

Tom Rockliff has won the Merrett-Murray Medal at Brisbane.

The top 10 are:

37.5 Tom Rockliff
35.5 Simon Black
35 Jack Redden
32.5 Jed Adcock
32.5 Pearce Hanley
31.5 Matthew Leuenberger
25 Ash McGrath
22 Todd Banfield
20.5 Daniel Merrett
20.5 Joel Patfull

[ledge]

Very surprised Leuenberger wasnt higher.

[The Coon Dog]

Very surprised Leuenberger wasnt higher.

Yeah, I thought that too, particularly given his second half of the year. Bit of a worry though that Daniel Rich can't crack a top 10 finish.

[mjp]

What is Brisbane's voting system? How do you get half votes?

[The Coon Dog]

Trent Cotchin has won the Jack Dyer Medal at Richmond.

The top 10 are:

236 Trent Cotchin
203 Brett Deledio
198 Dustin Martin
181 Bachar Houli
181 Ty Vickory
159 Alex Rance
159 Robin Nahas
150 Nathan Foley
149 Jack Riewoldt
137 Shaun Grigg

[mjp]

Wow - look at Richmond's top 10...could be their top 10 for the next 5 years!

[Mantis]

Wow - look at Richmond's top 10...could be their top 10 for the next 5 years!

It will be very interesting to compare the age of their top 10 to our's after our votes are released.

At the very least I would think that bar Griffen all of our top 5 will be over the age of 28.

[LostDoggy]

Wow - look at Richmond's top 10...could be their top 10 for the next 5 years!

It clearly means they have a young list, but do you think most of them will make good on their potential?

ps. Dustin Martin is a monster. Would love a player like that in our colours.

[The Coon Dog]

A Tie for the John Cahill Medal ot Port Adelaide between Jackson Trengove & Travis Boak. The new voting system (http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6038/newsid/123264/default.aspx)in place for the first time at Alberton.

The top 10 are:

13 Travis Boak
13 Jackson Trengove
10 Tom Logan
9 Robbie Gray
8 Danyle Pearce
8 Justin Westhoff
7 Alipate Carlile
7 Troy Chaplin
7 Hamish Hartlett
7 Jasper Pittard
7 David Rodan
7 Jay Schulz

[mjp]

I love Travis Boak.

[The Coon Dog]

No surprise with Brent Moloney winning the Bluey Truscott Trophy at Melbourne.

The top 10 are:

227 Brent Moloney
201 Jared Rivers
178 James Frawley
171 Nathan Jones
170 Jack Trengove
156 Colin Garland
154 Mark Jamar
147 Stefan Martin
145 Jack Watts
143 Colin Sylvia

[Go_Dogs]

I love Travis Boak.

Quality player. If he played in a half decent team, he'd be a superstar.

[Happy Days]

A Tie for the John Cahill Medal ot Port Adelaide between Jackson Trengove & Travis Boak. The new voting system (http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6038/newsid/123264/default.aspx)in place for the first time at Alberton.

The top 10 are:

13 Travis Boak
13 Jackson Trengove
10 Tom Logan
9 Robbie Gray
8 Danyle Pearce
8 Justin Westhoff
7 Alipate Carlile
7 Troy Chaplin
7 Hamish Hartlett
7 Jasper Pittard
7 David Rodan
7 Jay Schulz

Surely Trengove had it written into his contract that he had to win this B&F, no one at Port was even close to Boak this year.

[LostDoggy]

Tom Rockliff has won the Merrett-Murray Medal at Brisbane.

The top 10 are:

37.5 Tom Rockliff
35.5 Simon Black
35 Jack Redden
32.5 Jed Adcock
32.5 Pearce Hanley
31.5 Matthew Leuenberger
25 Ash McGrath
22 Todd Banfield
20.5 Daniel Merrett
20.5 Joel Patfull


What is Brisbane's voting system? How do you get half votes?

Just looked here for the first time, and wondering the same thing MJP.
Surely a BF count doesn't have to be this complicated? By round 24 drunk footballers wouldn't be able to follow this?

[The Coon Dog]

Probably not surprising that Marc Murphy won the Carlton B&F tonight, but probably what was surprising was just how much he won by.

The top 10 are:

678 Marc Murphy
469 Chris Judd
448 Bryce Gibbs
408 Heath Scotland
376 Kade Simpson
319 Andrew Walker
301 Mitch Robinson
285 Eddie Betts
257 Michael Jamison
237 Chris Yarran

[1eyedog]

Probably not surprising that Marc Murphy won the Carlton B&F tonight, but probably what was surprising was just how much he won by.

The top 10 are:

678 Marc Murphy
469 Chris Judd
448 Bryce Gibbs
408 Heath Scotland
376 Kade Simpson
319 Andrew Walker
301 Mitch Robinson
285 Eddie Betts
257 Michael Jamison
237 Chris Yarran

Knocked Judd of his perch by a fair way didn't he. Heath Scotland is like a good wine.

[The Coon Dog]

Another B&F tie, this time at North Melbourne where 1 vote gained by Andrew Swallow in round 24 was enough to level things up with Daniel Wells.

The top 10 are:

46 Daniel Wells
46 Andrew Swallow
36 Drew Petrie
36 Brent Harvey
35 Leigh Adams
30 Jack Ziebell
28 Todd Goldstein
26 Brady Rawlings
26 Aaron Edwards
25 Scott Thompson

[azabob]

Another B&F tie, this time at North Melbourne where 1 vote gained by Andrew Swallow in round 24 was enough to level things up with Daniel Wells.

The top 10 are:

46 Daniel Wells
46 Andrew Swallow
36 Drew Petrie
36 Brent Harvey
35 Leigh Adams
30 Jack Ziebell
28 Todd Goldstein
26 Brady Rawlings
26 Aaron Edwards
25 Scott Thompson

Well done to Wells. Hopefully his latest mishap (on the operating table of all places) doesn't effect his 2012 too much.

[The Coon Dog]

A bit of a surprise at Geelong with Corey Enright taking out the B&F. Most pundits had James Kelly winning this; he finished fourth.

Here are the top ten:

150 Corey Enright
143 Joel Corey
142 Jimmy Bartel
138 Cameron Ling
138 James Kelly
137 Joel Selwood
137 Matthew Scarlett
137 Steve Johnson
136 James Podsiadly
134 Harry Taylor

[Go_Dogs]

Geelong very surprising. I didn't think Enright had been quite as good as previous years.

[The Coon Dog]

Tonight & tomorrow night & all clubs would have completed their respective B&F counts.

[Maddog37]

A bit of a surprise at Geelong with Corey Enright taking out the B&F. Most pundits had James Kelly winning this; he finished fourth.

Here are the top ten:

150 Corey Enright
143 Joel Corey
142 Jimmy Bartel
138 Cameron Ling
138 James Kelly
137 Joel Selwood
137 Matthew Scarlett
137 Steve Johnson
136 James Podsiadly
134 Harry Taylor

Didn't Joel Corey miss a few with injury as well? Gun player.

[Greystache]

Didn't Joel Corey miss a few with injury as well? Gun player.

Neil Balme was explaining on SEN this morning they award players votes in every game based on their performance, but at the end they remove the 4 worst performances for the year, this takes out the element of games missed because they were planning to rest some players periodically and they didn't want this to penalise them on B&F night, and it also helps players who missed games through injury.

[The Coon Dog]

Pendlebury the winner at Collingwood.

The top 10 are:

65 Scott Pendlebury
54 Dane Swan
53 Travis Cloke
49 Luke Ball
47 Leon Davis
46 Dale Thomas
44 Ben Reid
43 Harry O'Brien
41 Jarryd Blair
40 Chris Tarrant

[The Coon Dog]

Matthew Boyd wins the 20111 Charles Sutton Medal.

The top 10 are:

140 Matthew Boyd
130 Robert Murphy
99 Ryan Griffen
84 Callan Ward
81 Dale Morris
74 Daniel Cross
72 Daniel Giansiracusa
66 Lian Picken
51 Barry Hall
42 Lukas Markovic
42 Shaun Higgins

[Sockeye Salmon]

Matthew Boyd wins the 20111 Charles Sutton Medal.

The top 10 are:

140 Matthew Boyd
130 Robert Murphy
99 Ryan Griffen
84 Callan Ward
81 Dale Morris
74 Daniel Cross
72 Daniel Giansiracusa
66 Lian Picken
51 Barry Hall
42 Lukas Markovic
42 Shaun Higgins

That's 11?

What odds do you think you would have got pre-season on Lukas Markovic polling more B & F votes than Brian Lake and Adam Cooney?

[The Coon Dog]

Big surprise at Essendon with David Zaharakis winning the B&F.

The top 10 are:

332 David Zaharakis
313 Brett Stanton
292 Michael Hurley
270 Jobe Watson
248 Heath Hocking
231 Dustin Fletcher
226 Dyson Heppell
225 Stewart Crameri
224 Paddy Ryder
216 Ben Howlett

[The Coon Dog]

That's 11?

Markovic & Higgins finished equal 10th.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Big surprise at Essendon with David Zaharakis winning the B&F.

The top 10 are:

332 David Zaharakis
313 Brett Stanton
292 Michael Hurley
270 Jobe Watson
248 Heath Hocking
231 Dustin Fletcher
226 Dyson Heppell
225 Stewart Crameri
224 Paddy Ryder
216 Ben Howlett

Didn't the Essendon fans want Stanton stoned at one point?

[The Coon Dog]

Adam Goodes tonight won his 3rd B&F at Sydney.

The top 10 are:

615 Adam Goodes
573 Rhyce Shaw
573 Josh Kennedy
542 Ryan O’Keefe
523 Ted Richards
519 Nick Smith
488 Daniel Hannebery
439 Shane Mumford
411 Ben McGlynn
396 Jarrad McVeigh

[ledge]

Matthew Boyd wins the 20111 Charles Sutton Medal.

The top 10 are:

140 Matthew Boyd
130 Robert Murphy
99 Ryan Griffen
84 Callan Ward
81 Dale Morris
74 Daniel Cross
72 Daniel Giansiracusa
66 Lian Picken
51 Barry Hall
42 Lukas Markovic
42 Shaun Higgins

Wow Markovic got more than young Liberatore.

[The Coon Dog]

Darren Glass won a thrilling vote count last night in Perth to claim the Eagles B&F. Glass tied on 398 votes with Matt Pridis but played 1 game less, so he wins on average, with Dean Cox 1 vote back.

The top 10 are:

398 Darren Glass
398 Matt Priddis
397 Dean Cox
374 Shannon Hurn
359 Luke Shuey
342 Adam Selwood
338 Nic Naitanui
333 Andrew Embley
333 Mark Nicoski
332 Scott Selwood

[The Coon Dog]

I thought Nick Dal Santo would have won the B&F at St.Kilda, but he was pipped in a thriller by Sam Fisher.

The top 10 are:

557 Sam Fisher
554 Nick Dal Santo
490 Sean Dempster
487 Leigh Montagna
418 Stephen Milne
401 Clint Jones
392 Adam Schneider
384 Nick Reiwoldt
376 Brendon Goddard
371 Jason Gram

[The Coon Dog]

No surprise at Hawthorn with Sam Mitchell winning the B&F.

The top 10 are:

177 Sam Mitchell
160 Josh Gibson
138 Grant Birchall
135 Lance Franklin
126 Luke Hodge
125 Jordan Lewis
105 Liam Shiels
103 Cyril Rioli
102 Brad Sewell
86 Shaun Burgoyne

[The Coon Dog]

Gee, thought Nate Fyfe would have won at Freo, but its a 6th B&F to Pav.

Here are the top 10:

144 Matthew Pavlich
141 Nathan Fyfe
118 Greg Broughton
103 Luke McPharlin
102 David Mundy
98 Aaron Sandilands
94 Stephen Hill
88 Antoni Grover
83 Hayden Ballantyne
72 Chris Mayne

[The Coon Dog]

Here's a wrap of the top 10 (or equal 10th) for all clubs:

Adelaide
83 Scott Thompson
50 Nathan van Berlo
38 Ben Rutten
38 Graham Johncock
35 Patrick Dangerfield
34 Rory Sloane
33 Bernie Vince
31 Sam Jacobs
28 Brent Reilly
25 Kurt Tippett

Brisbane
37.5 Tom Rockliff
35.5 Simon Black
35 Jack Redden
32.5 Jed Adcock
32.5 Pearce Hanley
31.5 Matthew Leuenberger
25 Ash McGrath
22 Todd Banfield
20.5 Daniel Merrett
20.5 Joel Patfull

Carlton
678 Marc Murphy
469 Chris Judd
448 Bryce Gibbs
408 Heath Scotland
376 Kade Simpson
319 Andrew Walker
301 Mitch Robinson
285 Eddie Betts
257 Michael Jamison
237 Chris Yarran

Collingwood
65 Scott Pendlebury
54 Dane Swan
53 Travis Cloke
49 Luke Ball
47 Leon Davis
46 Dale Thomas
44 Ben Reid
43 Harry O'Brien
41 Jarryd Blair
40 Chris Tarrant

Essendon
332 David Zaharakis
313 Brett Stanton
292 Michael Hurley
270 Jobe Watson
248 Heath Hocking
231 Dustin Fletcher
226 Dyson Heppell
225 Stewart Crameri
224 Paddy Ryder
216 Ben Howlett

Fremantle
144 Matthew Pavlich
141 Nathan Fyfe
118 Greg Broughton
103 Luke McPharlin
102 David Mundy
98 Aaron Sandilands
94 Stephen Hill
88 Antoni Grover
83 Hayden Ballantyne
72 Chris Mayne

Geelong
150 Corey Enright
143 Joel Corey
142 Jimmy Bartel
138 Cameron Ling
138 James Kelly
137 Joel Selwood
137 Matthew Scarlett
137 Steve Johnson
136 James Podsiadly
134 Harry Taylor

Gold Coast
196 Gary Ablett
138 Nathan Bock
100 Michael Rischitelli
98 David Swallow
95 Danny Stanley
93 Zac Smith
83 Jared Brennan
82 Jarrod Harbrow
49 Sam Iles
45 Harley Bennell
45 Trent McKenzie

Hawthorn
177 Sam Mitchell
160 Josh Gibson
138 Grant Birchall
135 Lance Franklin
126 Luke Hodge
125 Jordan Lewis
105 Liam Shiels
103 Cyril Rioli
102 Brad Sewell
86 Shaun Burgoyne

Melbourne
227 Brent Moloney
201 Jared Rivers
178 James Frawley
171 Nathan Jones
170 Jack Trengove
156 Colin Garland
154 Mark Jamar
147 Stefan Martin
145 Jack Watts
143 Colin Sylvia

North Melbourne
46 Daniel Wells
46 Andrew Swallow
36 Drew Petrie
36 Brent Harvey
35 Leigh Adams
30 Jack Ziebell
28 Todd Goldstein
26 Brady Rawlings
26 Aaron Edwards
25 Scott Thompson


Port Adelaide
13 Travis Boak
13 Jackson Trengove
10 Tom Logan
9 Robbie Gray
8 Danyle Pearce
8 Justin Westhoff
7 Alipate Carlile
7 Troy Chaplin
7 Hamish Hartlett
7 Jasper Pittard
7 David Rodan
7 Jay Schulz

Richmond
236 Trent Cotchin
203 Brett Deledio
198 Dustin Martin
181 Bachar Houli
181 Ty Vickory
159 Alex Rance
159 Robin Nahas
150 Nathan Foley
149 Jack Riewoldt
137 Shaun Grigg

St.Kilda
557 Sam Fisher
554 Nick Dal Santo
490 Sean Dempster
487 Leigh Montagna
418 Stephen Milne
401 Clint Jones
392 Adam Schneider
384 Nick Reiwoldt
376 Brendon Goddard
371 Jason Gram

Sydney
615 Adam Goodes
573 Rhyce Shaw
573 Josh Kennedy
542 Ryan O’Keefe
523 Ted Richards
519 Nick Smith
488 Daniel Hannebery
439 Shane Mumford
411 Ben McGlynn
396 Jarrad McVeigh

West Coast
398 Darren Glass
398 Matt Priddis
397 Dean Cox
374 Shannon Hurn
359 Luke Shuey
342 Adam Selwood
338 Nic Naitanui
333 Andrew Embley
333 Mark Nicoski
332 Scott Selwood

Western Bulldogs
140 Matthew Boyd
130 Robert Murphy
99 Ryan Griffen
84 Callan Ward
81 Dale Morris
74 Daniel Cross
72 Daniel Giansiracusa
66 Lian Picken
51 Barry Hall
42 Lukas Markovic
42 Shaun Higgins

[chef]

Thanks TCD.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Gee, thought Nate Fyfe would have won at Freo, but its a 6th B&F to Pav.

Here are the top 10:

144 Matthew Pavlich
141 Nathan Fyfe
118 Greg Broughton
103 Luke McPharlin
102 David Mundy
98 Aaron Sandilands
94 Stephen Hill
88 Antoni Grover
83 Hayden Ballantyne
72 Chris Mayne

Didn't Mundy get injured in about round 6?

[Jasper]

Darren Glass won a thrilling vote count last night in Perth to claim the Eagles B&F. Glass tied on 398 votes with Matt Pridis but played 1 game less, so he wins on average, with Dean Cox 1 vote back.

The top 10 are:

398 Darren Glass
398 Matt Priddis
397 Dean Cox
374 Shannon Hurn
359 Luke Shuey
342 Adam Selwood
338 Nic Naitanui
333 Andrew Embley
333 Mark Nicoski
332 Scott Selwood

Does it not seem illogical to punish the guy who played more games?
Surely just award a tie.
Maybe Priddis had a bigger bonus in his contract if he won the B&F

[The Coon Dog]

Does it not seem illogical to punish the guy who played more games?
Surely just award a tie.
Maybe Priddis had a bigger bonus in his contract if he won the B&F

Yup, agree with that.

[LostDoggy]

Matthew Boyd wins the 20111 Charles Sutton Medal.

The top 10 are:

140 Matthew Boyd
130 Robert Murphy
99 Ryan Griffen
84 Callan Ward
81 Dale Morris
74 Daniel Cross
72 Daniel Giansiracusa
66 Lian Picken
51 Barry Hall
42 Lukas Markovic
42 Shaun Higgins

I guess this reflects where our list is at -- the major concern being that of the only two players on that list that can be considered 'young', one plays primarily as a tagger and the other has moved to Sydney's west.

I suppose Markovic is young-ish but will probably never be a superstar, and Higgins is only young if you go by his birthdate -- he's old if you go by his injury-wracked body.

Glad Griff looks to have a few years left in him though.