Trade Rumours 2024

[bornadog]

Please

Ask a dumb question, get a dumb answer

[EasternWest]

Ask a dumb question, get a dumb answer

It's a garbage position.

If you felt that way about JHF (which you did, you explicitly complained that he was roughing up Libba who was "one concussion from retirement") how on earth can you justify wanting to trade for him five minutes later?

Either he should be sacked for what he did (according to you) or what he did was fine and we should pursue him (according to you).

I know we're all upset right now and this too will pass but I find these convenient inconsistencies so tedious.

[bornadog]

It's a garbage position.

If you felt that way about JHF (which you did, you explicitly complained that he was roughing up Libba who was "one concussion from retirement") how on earth can you justify wanting to trade for him five minutes later?

Either he should be sacked for what he did (according to you) or what he did was fine and we should pursue him (according to you).

I know we're all upset right now and this too will pass but I find these convenient inconsistencies so tedious.

I thought Game day thread was - what is said there stays there, but oh no you have to bring it? If it is tedious just don't respond

[EasternWest]

I thought Game day thread was - what is said there stays there, but oh no you have to bring it? If it is tedious just don't respond

Why would I not respond? Should I not respond if it's funny? Should I not respond if it's accurate? Should I only respond if it fits a certain criteria?

Nah, I think on this forum for discussion I'll just keep discussing.
i love you for your dogged loyalty but sometimes what you say is so contradictory that it needs a checking.

[Happy Days]

I thought Game day thread was - what is said there stays there, but oh no you have to bring it? If it is tedious just don't respond

He’s got a point EW.

[bornadog]

why would i not respond? Should i not respond if it's funny? Should i not respond if it's accurate? Should i only respond if it fits a certain criteria?

Nah, i think on this forum for discussion i'll just keep discussing.
I love you for your dogged loyalty but sometimes what you say is so contradictory that it needs a checking.

game day thread

[EasternWest]

He?s got a point EW.

game day thread

Lol, you two.

I'm J Cole ing out of here. I don't know what that means but I assume it means leave with style or something.

[Grantysghost]

Sam Berry from the Crows hasn't put pen to paper yet. Young mid who I think goes ok however maybe another that doesn't have the speed for modern midfield.

I'd certainly be interested as a younger midfielder who always appears to work hard when given the chance.

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/07/...r-collingwood/

[GVGjr]

Sam Berry from the Crows hasn't put pen to paper yet. Young mid who I think goes ok however maybe another that doesn't have the speed for modern midfield.

I'd certainly be interested as a younger midfielder who always appears to work hard when given the chance.

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/07/...r-collingwood/

I don't mind that suggestion at all. Seems to have some upside to his game.

[Mofra]

Other than Barrass have we been linked with anyone else? I see Ned McHenry is no the outer with the Crows. He might be a decent option up forward.

I saw us linked with Tomlinson a few weeks ago. I assume we have a back up option or two if(when) Barrass falls over.

McHenry can certainly cover ground. It's everything else I'm not sure on.

[Mofra]

Sam Berry from the Crows hasn't put pen to paper yet. Young mid who I think goes ok however maybe another that doesn't have the speed for modern midfield.

I'd certainly be interested as a younger midfielder who always appears to work hard when given the chance.

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/07/...r-collingwood/

Wouldn't we just give those extra minutes to Sanders?

[JanLorMill]

I saw us linked with Tomlinson a few weeks ago. I assume we have a back up option or two if(when) Barrass falls over.

McHenry can certainly cover ground. It's everything else I'm not sure on.

Sorry not trying to shoot the messenger but there has hardly been a season in the 5/6 where we haven’t been linked to Tomlinson. Surely we have dodged that bullet.

[bornadog]

Sorry not trying to shoot the messenger but there has hardly been a season in the 5/6 where we haven’t been linked to Tomlinson. Surely we have dodged that bullet.

Yeah I am not a fan of his at all

[Happy Days]

They’re right. I’ve posted “Tomlinson sucks so bad” for at least six off seasons in here.

[Go_Dogs]

If Lobb is actually a defender, and we’ve extended Buss and probably should be developing Croft as a forward, do we need Barass? I’m less excited by the prospect than I was 2 weeks ago. I know Jones won’t play forever, but we need more elite midfield talent - maybe JF is already that man?

Plenty to play out still this year.